Other than the fee paid, how is asking JA for his opinion on a slabbed coin any different than asking a respected dealer or numismatist? If I post a pic and ask what the group thinks, does that also mean that the finalizer is irrelevant?
I'm not saying CAC is good or bad, just trying to understand why you keep pushing your disdain for something that the hobby appears to have embraced.
Knowledge is power. The more proficient you are at grading, the better chance you'll have of buying great coins that will be easy to resell when the time comes. if you have a solid coin, a good dealer will know it regardless of if it's slabbed, beaned, or whatever. They still may lowball you, but if you know your stuff, you'll find a buyer.
Right, wrong, or indifferent, that's how the game Is played today. You can sit in the corner and "hurumph" until the cows come home, but don't expect people to change their way if thinking because you don't like it. Just my thoughts