Jason Abshier

The 36’ and 43’ look sharply struck by looking at skirt lines possibly get 65+ or 66 grade is they are P mint mark not worth sending in 42’ or 43’ unless they are D or S mint . However the 36’ is nice worth sending in even if it gets 65 grade it still worthy grading holds some value again you buy them graded already like everyone else is saying … do you have pictures of the reverse of the coins? The eagle’s breast feather determines the grade on back of the coin

Cool coin , or medallion or whatever you call it … something different ! I don’t know why some folks on here are giving you a hard time over little coin out of all honesty it sometimes gets real boring on here seeing and constantly talking about “US coinage” which 90% of US coins are ugliest coins on earth ever made but 90% of folks on here know no better but to only collect “US coinage” everything else is garbage … My brother a few years asked if I saved any of our hot wheel cars from back in late 60’s and 70’s we had hundreds and hundreds of them when we were little when we gotten tired of playing with a certain car we used to lay them on railroad track “crushing time” we called it .. Sadly not knowing we crushed some well sought out collectible hot wheel cars , back then we never thought they would be collectibles on today’s market . Goes to show who knows what the future holds for certain collectibles … We did the same thing to garbage pal kid cards we collected in 80’s damaged and abused them some of them cards are worth hundreds and hundreds of dollars on today’s market

I’ve dealt with them in the past , I’ve also sold a bunch of coins to them for their inventory about 16 years ago if I recall it was long while back. Also bought a lot high graded old world Coins and few gold coins off them over the years they are easy to work and haggle with on prices they are motivated dealer that doesn’t turn down offers

@Woods020 I asked yesterday if Greysheet was wholesale bid for dealer sight seen slabbed coins . Blue sheet is also whole sale bid as sight unseen for lower end slabbed value coins and raw coins . I haven’t seen a Greysheet for years but last time I looked it was always Bid and ask prices among dealer to dealer only at wholesale prices perhaps it may have changed over the years that I’m not aware of it’s more retail priced? I noticed the prices where never near retail prices that you and I would pay to buy a coin from a dealer but it been about 10 years since I looked at the Greysheet

I was about to hire him , leave my coin list with him he would be able to get them all for me at 80% off . I almost believed my dreams came true 🤣

80% ? Really I have see that to believe it if a coin is worth $200 (retail value) you want to only buy for $40 ?

I always though Greysheet was wholesale sight seen coins certified , bluesheet was for sight “unseen” wholesale both raw and certified Coins either one was no where near yearly posted retail values . I guess I was wrong

I only use NGC/PCGS price guide for graded coins as reference I like PCGS sometimes because they show auction prices for some of graded coins that have sold it shows prices scattered for a range of coins in different grades I narrow it down a lot time I only deal online with “best offers” on coins a lot dealers are workable some of them don’t mention they accept “best offers” but it doesn’t hurt to ask . Another place is heritage auctions and few others gives you better idea what people are paying . Is buying the price book practical when we have power of internet to google whatever we want ? Greysheet is nice it doesn’t do you much good as the “buyer” the Greysheet is for what a dealer buys coins at wholesale on a spread it gives you an idea what a dealer should or would pay for your coins if you were to sell to dealer only

Altoona is another one that sounds like “Al tuna”

A majority of high end world coins are “top pop” cause not many of them were sent in for grading you often see the Top pop in graded NGC/PCGS world coin and medals category that can change in next several years from now when more and more world coins or medals are being sent in for grading it’s a slow growing market in the US here and small crowd of collectors with a heart and passion for true numismatic beyond US coinage

Warsh-rag is another word I always say that throws people off or warshing-machine . Go warsh the dishes I often tell my wife when she gets on my nerves

Us Pittsburgh natives have odd accent like we say “crick” instead of Creek ! Or yinzers… few other odd words we say that puzzles people 2 years ago I went down Camp Lejeune to see my oldest son he was station at Marine Corp base . The wife and I went down rented a beach house near the beach and to see him for few days for his re-enlistment sworn oath ceremony. I asked him what cooked meal he misses the most back home ? He said “Islay’s BBQ chipped ham sandwiches” I told him I’ll make it now back at the beach house, went to store deli section asked guy for chipped ham . He was confused I told him Pittsburgh style ham he had no clue ! Funny I told him set slicer up cut ham paper thin and chop it against the blade into crumbled pieces … All it is chipped ham , ketchup , little brown sugar or molasses, dill relish and little corn starch thicken up sauce and burger buns … And there ya go got yourself a islay’s BBQ chipped ham sandwich

1969-s double die you’ll know it when you see it you can’t miss it “in god we trust” major doubling and in Liberty as well … I’ve only examined one at coin show few years back never found any in my penny searches

I’ve never seen coins breed before to obtain a pedigree , when folks use that word I think of a dog’s pedigree and it’s ancestry where it came from . but it sometimes mistakenly used in coin collector’s world .

Get yourself cherry picker’s guide , most of the older dates coins already been covered , newer modern stuff is found from time to time … I’m not error collector but I have friend who collects a lot error coins , your coin is pretty banged up and worn down even if there was an “error” on it too damaged nobody would want it . Also the more worn down and banged up a coin gets it gets hard to see the errors on it . But if error collecting amuses you buy the book study and study as much as you can and good luck welcome to forums as well

I definitely look into it . Thanks for information … I was drinking a yuengling beer you name on here popped up

I gotta get me some RWB books to go along with my RWB beer !

That make more sense to me , I can live with small nick or gouge in the outer field of the coin or around the rim edges but not smack dabbed right in middle of the coin’s design , if it were plain old bullion like a silver eagle for investment purposes I wouldn’t mind … it’s like collecting Morgan dollars a lot of them have scratches and scuffs all over the coins from being in mint bags we have choice keep looking for a better Morgan with lesser scuff marks it is what it is . But proof coins struck for collectors there shouldn’t be any marks like that each customer pays the same amount money to receive the mint’s best of the best . That’s why they make proof coins for collectors to show customers how good they can mint a coin or how good their QC is when they are striking coins for collectors . Although I don’t plan on sending any of my silver coins in for grading they don’t warrant the price tag to me to be graded but I still like and admire a collector’s coin that was well struck and handled properly before it arrived to my door

They are supposed to fix the problem right there before it creates more problems down line , it could of happened at end of production …. I work in machine shop for living setting up CNC machines and manufacturing precision bearings for customers believe me tight tolerances are a must there not short cut or “if it got a scratch or dent we’ll send it out anyways hope and pray customer understands us we tried our best” …. Time is money to some people, a good experience machinist doesn’t scrap parts especially large parts weigh over 1-2ton big solid chunk of steel …A good QC person makes world of difference 2nd set of eyes make sure everything measuring right all tolerance are clicking in before it ships out to customer …. Yeah maybe my machining background is interfering with way I’m look at mint making modern coins with newer technology coin presses and better dies with nicks , gouges , scratches are not acceptable should be fixed . Or if someone is handling them rough before encapsulated them ? That person should be trained better … so getting real ? Goes a long way me when it comes to manufacturing

@Walter Holmesdid you get your coins through Pobjoy mint ? I’ve heard of other who ordered from that mint weren’t to happy with their customer service or minting they did on some coins … Funny farm mint ! Probably have a QC guy with poor eyesight wearing glasses thick as the bottom of glass coke bottle looking at those coins coming off the minting press

Are you serious ? They said that ? Lol! If they told me that I wouldn’t do business with them again . That’s BS right there they are supposed offer clean , honest business and fair prices to each and every customer, the prices shouldn’t increase because you want to have the coins graded. Sounds like they were being smarta** towards you about it or simply because they are too stupid or don’t care or have Q.C looking at coins when they are striking them … Low mintage coins? Each coin should be carefully struck few times on high pressure to fully bring out best of the dies on the coin and handled right away in capsules . My coin I’m sending it back to vendor who I purchased it through in return he shipping me another one back , he will ship the one I’m sending back to him back to mint to get a replacement

Sorry hear about your father passing away …. The Krause price guide book is for world coins , if they are older Great Britain coins most of the old old Great Britain coinage is worth something they were made of out silver but they are plentiful there are several world coins that carry high premiums if you know what your looking at … but sounds of it your father was collecting in bulk loads at one time and still to today a lot coin dealers sold world coins in bulk loads … The US market and collectors/dealers tend to look down on “world coins” like they are trash or something nothing better than US coinage at one time it was easier to buy scarce world coins because dealers didn’t want anything to do with them they focused on US coinage and market for US coins … Now a days some dealers see some world coins are worth more than some US coins they are starting to grow in the market today but still a “small crowd” of collectors but some of the designs on world coins , makes US coinage look plain and simple like they were minted by little kid engraving the dies at the mint some of world coins the designs and dates that go way way back painstakingly engraved in dies with fine such details (some aren’t worth anything but only beauty in the eyes of beholder)… Take your time to learn about them , separate all coins in to country , and denomination break it down from there look on eBay or auctions to find out what coins you have also some people collected to be collectors they didn’t care about future “how much money am I going to get for this and so on” some folks didn’t see collecting like it was their retirement plan so collecting lower value coins was their goals just to put a collection together …

You’re not alone I just ordered a ST. Helena Queen’s virtues Victory angel silver round that has nick just behind the Queen’s eye ! Your post Jinxed me ! I’m sending mine back

Probably come out with a 5oz Morgan and peace dollar

I feel your pain! Did you get these directly from the mint or dealer ? Hopefully they take them back . Hopefully you can get a replacement if they aren’t all sold out . You should contact mint directly show them the pictures of gouge on the coin