I hate to say it JAnsley, but it definitely looks like a cast fake to me. There are a lot of those for this particular issue floating around. I'd say at this point, there are likely more fakes of this coin than genuine examples in existence. But at $40, it could have been worse. I've known people who paid a lot higher rate of numismatic tuition learning in this hobby. And fakes can happen to any of us. About a decade ago, I bought a very convincing fake of a rare Ottoman gold 100 Kurush.....that one was a major ouch!!! I ended up getting gold melt out of it and that was all.....so, I lost a lot more than $40!!! It happens. Just pick yourself up, dust yourself off and get back in the game!