Yes and no, currently no because the spot price of gold is at all-time highs coins that have issues or are impaired in some way (like ex jewelry coins) are selling for the same prices as unimpaired coins that grade in the AU range. Your coin would have to grade in MS64 or better to rise above the current spot gold price which today was around $2,162 per ounce. The only real difference is it can be easier to sell an unimpaired coin to a coin collector who may not want such an impaired coin. Most dealers would sell this for spot + 5%, they would buy it at spot - 5%.
Yes if, and this is a big if, in the future should the spot price of gold retreat, that is when you could see a difference in value for your ex jewelry coin vs an unimpaired AU coin.