Should I give NCS a swing at these Liberty proofs? 0

[ldhair]

What are your thoughts?

1884 NGS PF-64

1887 PCGS PF-63

1898 PCI Early green label PF-64

 

[DWLange]

Those do appear to be good candidates for NCS conservation.

[numisport]

IMO the '84 and the '98 could have eye appeal improved (if they will conserve). But you could lose a grade if a couple hairlines are revealed when the haze is removed.

[RWB]

All will be improved by removing superficial contamination (haze). The "grade" is what it is.

[ldhair]

Thank you everyone. I will be sending them in. I'll post the results.

[DWLange]

If you're willing to pay the additional $18 fee for variety attribution, your 1884 has a repunched date variety recognized by NGC. Be sure to click the PF tab at upper right to see the proof varieties:

https://www.ngccoin.com/variety-plus/united-states/nickels/liberty-head-five-cents-1883-1913/?page=1

[Hoghead515]

Those are some beauties. Cant wait to see  them after theyre done. I think they are gorgeous in the current condition now. Id say if we we lived to be that old we would have a little haze to. I bet they will really be amazing when its removed. Please share when you get them back. I really enjoy admiring old coins like that. 

[Hoghead515]

The 1898 looks like a cameo to me. I could be wrong though. Im no coin grader but those are stunning.