Guess the grades from my last submission! (Grades REVEALED!)

[jtryka]

Ok, I submitted my 5 freebies from my collectors society membership at the Chicago ANA, and they arrived back to me today. I'll post some photos and for fun, try to guess the grades! And for the record, I felt that on the whole these grades were pretty accurate, though some I would have liked something higher, and others I was pleasantly surprised. Oh, and the scratch on the 1803 is on the holder, yeah I've only had these back for 5 hours and I've already scratched a slab! Here are the first 5 images:

 

[jtryka]

Here are the other 5 images:

 

[noow]

Nice coins!

 

1803- EF45

1805- VF35

1828- AU58

1880- MS63PL

1884- AU Det. OBV damage

 

 

 

[mtnstyne]

1880S Morgan MS64

[noow]

PS

The look on that Morgan is nice!

[$ilverHawk]

1803 F15

1805 F12

1828 XF40

1880 MS63

1834 VF20

 

Carl

 

 

[jtryka]

Here are the grades from NGC:

 

1803 50C O-103 VF-30

1805 50C O-108 F-15

1828 50C O-116 XF-45

1880-S $1 MS-64

1834 $5 Plain 4 Obv. Damage XF Details

[physics-fan3.14]

Did the Morgan get PL?

[jtryka]

Nope. I think the reverse had it, but the obverse just wasn't PL enough.

[bsshog40]

Not bad results. That nic on the gold sux. I agree also on the morgan. Just a little more on the Obv and it would've made it. Nice tho'!

[noow]

So close to a PL.