What did NGC think? (results in last post)

[MJ]

I recently sent in the three coins below for a star review through a dealer friend of mine. None of the coins have been sent in prior to our knowledge and we have a pretty good idea where these have been the past ten years. The Walker was ONLY re-holdered recently and sat in an older NGC holder prior.We received the results of the review on Friday.

 

Question- How many IF any, received the Star? 0,1,2 or all 3? Only one guess per person. To add a little intrigue we will play for an ASE....... In case of ties, I have a fair tie breaker in mind. State which coin or coin(s) you think star'd with your answer. Those who guess zero will be picked out of a hat in case of a tie.............MJ

 

a) 67 Gettysburg pic by Brandon Kelley

 

Same Gettysburg- Pic by Mark Goodman

 

b) 67 34-P Walker pic by Todd Pollack

 

c) 66 Maine pic by Mark Goodman

[comicdonna]

I will guess 1 (A)

[tejas1836]

I'm going to say "a" got the star but it wouldn't surprise if they all did.

[djdilliodon]

0 got the star is my guess.

[rons]

I like all three but believe that only c received the star.

[bartlesvilleok]

a & b

 

[Schatzy]

I like all 3!!

 

The walker looks to dark for a star.

 

My vote is for the first one!!

[123cents]

I guess just B got the star.

[bsshog40]

I say 0 also.

[ldhair]

All really cool coins.

B&C got a star.

[physics-fan3.14]

I have seen ugly coins get stars and far prettier coins not get stars. I have no clue.

 

But for the purposes of the contest, I will hope you got lucky and say you got stars on all three.

[Denver Dave]

I'll go with B & C although I love all three...

 

 

[jtryka]

I guess that all three got a star!

[History Student]

I LOVE all three.

 

Especailly the 2010 type reverse on the Getty.

 

IMVHO + + +

 

but who knows, right?

 

 

I've had way more than ONE come back with a toe tag: AKA BODY BAGED.

[michael]

thanks for the chance

 

walker and gettysburg starred

[jesbroken]

I did not peek, so my guess would be (b) the Walker won the star and was the only one to get a star.

Jim

[lehigh96]

I like all three but believe that only c received the star.

 

I second this. The first two both have areas that approach black which would disqualify them from the star designation.

[robec1347]

All are beauties. I'll go with A and C for the star.

[L1ncolnF4n]

2

A and C

 

Walker is a hair too dark, although it is a stunning piece.

[MercuryMan]

Wow nice coins!! That Gettysburg is just tops...oh yea there's a question here...I'll go with

2 the A and B coin.

 

Thanks for the contest and for showing those coins.

[cpm9ball]

I say "B" got a star for the strike.

 

Chris

[dean1345]

All 3

[mommam17]

I would say only the Maine got a star.

[kryptonitecomics]

Zero...none got the star

[rrantique]

Zero...none got the star

 

Their all stars in my book. Nice coins MJ (thumbs u

[MarkFeld]

I like all three but believe that only c received the star.

 

I second this. The first two both have areas that approach black which would disqualify them from the star designation.

I'll go with C (the Maine) too.

[SkyMan]

Just the Maine, e.g. C.

[FILTHYHOARD]

All three are beauties in my book, but lately NGC has been tough with the stars, so I vote for NONE

[Bugmann1974]

I will guess that only the Gettysburg got a star.

[praedator-migration]

All three are very nice! I am going to guess two of them got the star A and B.