Quiet around here... Grade some GOLD!

[MunkyMan95]

 

What do you grade it?

 

 

Seller's images

[Mirrored Morgan]

I would say around AU50

[jtryka]

Looks like there is damage on the obverse field or at least a really big ding, I would grade it XF-40, net VF.

[MunkyMan95]

Yep, there is a pretty big ding, but it's not net graded (at least not noted on the holder), or BB'd. It's in a slab.

[jtryka]

That's surprising, I suppose it must not look as bad in hand, then I'll go with my first instinct, XF-40.

[bsshog40]

Looks like has some nice detail & luster, just alot of chatter. I'm not good at grading this type of stuff Chad, but I'll shoot for maybe AU50.

[MunkyMan95]

I'm not good at grading this type of stuff

 

You're not alone

[ldhair]

I don't know enough about gold but I would guess AU-50.

I'm wondering if the small hit on the obverse would effect the grade? I don't get to see a lot of graded gold. Do the grading services hold silver to a bit higher standard?

I like the coin.

[MunkyMan95]

I'm wondering if the small hit on the obverse would effect the grade?

 

In this particular case, I think it did.

 

 

Guess accordingly!

[MBA101]

My wild guess would be EF-45...

[123cents]

My wild guess would be EF-45...

 

I'll second that wild guess and say EF-45 too.

[construct]

I'll say 40.

[MunkyMan95]

Well guys, here it is. Take it as you will. Jeff was the closest, just barely missing. Maybe it was downgraded because of the hit, without being net graded.

 

[jtryka]

Not a bad coin overall though I like it! When will you be sending it to me?

[MunkyMan95]

For 160 years old, it's not a bad coin at all. I'm flattered that you want it

 

This one's going to be tucked away for many years down the road.

[rbrown4]

Here is another Gold Coin for guessing the Grade

 

1907 D Half Eagle.

 

Rey

 

 

[rrantique]

That's a great golden oldie Chad

 

I'll guess Ms-64 Rey

[Dwaine]

I will go with MS-65.

[Oldtrader3]

Picture looks nice. I will go with MS64 just because of chatter on the neck and small luster breaks. Can't tell from photo if small red spots are copper or not?

[MunkyMan95]

Grade this one. Die polish lines, not cleaning.

 

[rrantique]

That is a hard one to grade Chad Ms-62?

[jtryka]

That 07-D is really nice, I would go MS-64 with a good shot at a 65, but I know that most TPG's grade liberty gold very tough!

 

Chad, the 1880-D, if they are really die polish lines, maybe MS-62, but man she is an ugly beast!

[rbrown4]

The 1907 D Half Eagle was MS 65.

 

Rey

[MunkyMan95]

Chad, the 1880-D, if they are really die polish lines, maybe MS-62, but man she is an ugly beast!

 

I think she's kinda purdy!

[rrantique]

That's beauty Rey i graded too conservatively

[rbrown4]

Thanks Irvin.

 

Chad I am going to say MS 62 on the 1880 S

 

Rey

[MunkyMan95]

It's an S! 1880-S!

[rrantique]

That is why i gave it a WAG (wild S guess)

[michael]

well after the fact

 

1844 half eagle

 

apparent vf35 cleaned, damaged

[construct]

1880-S

 

62