New Pickup Toning Morgan Dollars & Peace Dollar

[A.Phillips]

I bought 3 of dollars from local flea market today. I am kinda of disappointed with dealer because he didn't told me that 1896 Morgan has a damage on bottom rim, it was cover by foam until I open it at home. However it has a nice toning on reverse. I am not sure if it's NT or AT on 1896. The 1880 Morgan was cracked out from NGC MS61. I normally don't collecting Peace Dollar, but I bought this one, 1923-S, because it has light pink, blue, and yellow toning on obverse.

 

1896-P

 

 

 

1880-P

 

 

 

1923-S Peace Dollar, its hard to take a better picture. It would be easier if I break the holder and take a picture of this raw Peace.

 

 

[bsshog40]

Nice looking pickups. Looks like just a small ding on the 96' but still purty!!

[No+4Me]

The Morgans look like they were kept in an old album, like Wayte Raymond type. Why not leave the Peace $ in the holder? You don't see those old ANACS ones around much any more and they are sort of cool, imo. Nice coin!

[Walkerfan]

The Peace dollar looks real nice. I don't like the rim nick on the 1896 but it has some decent color.

[A.Phillips]

I want to add other pictures of 1880 Morgan Dollar, I am able to shoot a picture with better light.

 

 

[Walkerfan]

Much better image of the 1880. The obverse has a prominent scratch on the cheek---I am not sure that this would be a grading factor or not. I like the color of the reverse, though.

[A.Phillips]

Thank you for the kind words. I have forgotten all about Wayte Raymond style, that's what I am wondering if that Morgans were in an old album that cause the tone on Morgans?

[A.Phillips]

Much better image of the 1880. The obverse has a prominent scratch on the cheek---I am not sure that this would be a grading factor or not. I like the color of the reverse, though.

 

Yeah it has a scratch on the cheek, it was in NGC MS61 holder. I crack it out this afternoon because the holder was dilapidated.

[Walkerfan]

Much better image of the 1880. The obverse has a prominent scratch on the cheek---I am not sure that this would be a grading factor or not. I like the color of the reverse, though.

 

Yeah it has a scratch on the cheek, it was in NGC MS61 holder. I crack it out this afternoon because the holder was dilapidated.

 

I would have guessed 62 or 63. Nice coin.

[TonerGuy]

The 23-S Peace is very nice. Its NT and probably undergraded by 1-2 pts. For a S mint coin it has a very nice strike through the hair and on the reverse Eagle's wing.

 

I would leave it in that holder or submit it to CAC or even NGC for an upgrade. An MS64 coin is a substantial difference in $$$.

[johnny9434]

it looks like ya did pretty good over all.

[Mr.Mcknowitall]

The 23-S Peace is very nice. Its NT and probably undergraded by 1-2 pts. For a S mint coin it has a very nice strike through the hair and on the reverse Eagle's wing.

 

I would leave it in that holder or submit it to CAC or even NGC for an upgrade. An MS64 coin is a substantial difference in $$$.

 

Will CAC evaluate/opinionate/guessigate/procrastinate an ANACS graded coin?

 

PS: I think I combined all the possible CAC "ates", based on previous Threads.

If not, added "ates" are welcome.

[TonerGuy]

Will CAC evaluate/opinionate/guessigate/procrastinate an ANACS graded coin?

 

Ahhhh... I forgot they dont "do" ANACs coins... my bad. As you can tell I dont submit coins to CAC ...