The importance of the initial impression of a coin

[FISTer-migration]

I'm in a quandary, a 3cN that I spoke of not winning on eBay has become available. My initial impression was very high, and I still like it a lot. The quandary is that I will be going to the Myrtle Beach show to meet with a dealer who I spoke to about war nickels. Do I spend the $500-600 for this coin, and only have around $500 left for the show, or should I save it all for the show? My first impressions of this coin have been very high. Any input on it is very welcome, the seller has perfect feedback and I really like the color of the coin in the picture.

 

[mkman123]

You seem to like the coin a lot so I say buy it or you might regret not getting it

[mtnstyne]

What is the chance that you will be able to find this coin or a comparible coin in the future vs being able to find the war nickels you are looking for? I would think the 3CN is going to be more difficult to find again but that's just me.

 

 

[FISTer-migration]

I haven't seen this coloration on any other 3cN. On the other hand, finding decent 3cN is easy they are all over eBay. Finding war nickels that are toned how I like is proving very difficult.

[jerseycat10]

I am not a fan of 3cn, but that example is breathtaking. I would acquire that coin, and spend the rest at the show.

[michael]

just saw the coin come up before it was red X

 

pm sent

[physics-fan3.14]

That looks like a stunning 3cn - if you can get it for $500-$600, you are getting a great deal on a fantastic coin. If you are in the market for this - Buy It!

[Kamillion]

you found something you like

go for it

[Raisethis2]

That coin has some pop. I'd think it might be tough to find another for the price you like as much.

[PerryHall]

Neat die clash---gives the coin character.

[relicsncoins]

Looks nice in the photos. I wonder if it has been to the sticker mill.

 

[nunfa0]

Grab it now!!

[Timely]

I like it.

It seems like you really like it.

"A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush!"

[James_OldeTowne]

It depends on your reasons for buying it. As a "type", it may not be ideal, since you can get a better 1888 in an early die-state with a better impression of the design. For that matter, a more common date in higher grade might be a better alternative.

 

But if you like the coin for some reason not mentioned, then go for it!

[Buffalo Head]

This piece looks very appealing. It also has some cool clashing on the reverse which is typical for the series, I think. Still it's cool. I really like these little nickel pieces....Joe

[Arizonadesertrat]

If a single coin for a type set is what the OP is looking for, I would keep looking---this one isn't fully struck. 3CNs are quiet, easy to find in 65 and up, and the nice clash marks on the reverse are actually rather common (this is generally true of small coins, like gold $1s, H10Cs, 3CSs, 3CNs). As another poster stated, an early die state piece would likely make for a better type coin.

[Kurtdog]

Ah, love at first sight. One thing about it, it saves a lot of time.

[Catbert]

I think first impressions are important since they are an indicator of what you will treasure. If you look at it in hand carefully and there isn't anything that changes your opinion, then I suggest you buy it.

[MarkFeld]

If the images are accurate, the coin looks to be uncommonly attractive for the type and grade.

[messydesk]

I've bought a couple coins that aren't in my specialty because of an instant connection I felt. During the decision process, I said to myself, "Why do you want that coin? It's not in your specialty." I then said to myself, "So what? That's an attractive coin, I find nothing objectionable about it, and it's cool." This may be such an opportunity for you. Objectively, as a type coin, I'd probably lean toward an earlier date with better defined features and no die clashes or cracks, but when a coin grabs you and is fairly priced, sometimes it best to grab back.

[Oldtrader3]

I think that initial impressions are important, especially if it is a coin series that you are familiar with. Sometimes I find something upon closer inspection that may change my mind on a coin but the eye appeal factor of that first impression is sometimes an excellent indicator.