Generic Morgans - Grades Reveled in Last Post

[FishyOne]

I picked up a couple generic Morgans last week and have them in hand now.

 

These are the seller's pics and they look better in-hand. What grades do you think NGC assigned?

 

1884-O Seller's Images:

 

 

My Images:

 

 

1880-S Seller's Images:

 

 

My images:

 

[bsshog40]

First off, both are nice Morgans. I think the first would be MS63 and the second looks like would get MS64. Close to PL but I don't think so.

[rrantique]

My kinda coins. I like em. (thumbs u

 

84 O 63+

80 S 64

[mtnstyne]

MS63

MS64+

[James_OldeTowne]

I'll guess MS-63 "star", and MS-64.

[physics-fan3.14]

I'll guess 64 and 65PL

[Bruceswar]

I'll guess MS-63 "star", and MS-64.

 

This !

[C.I.]

MS64

MS65

[JOBESSI]

I'll guess MS-63 "star", and MS-64.

 

(thumbs u

[relicsncoins]

63* and 64PL is my guess.

[FishyOne]

You guys are good! These are nice pieces not subject to gradeflation! The 1880-S is close to PL and close to 65 - a true 64. The 1884-O is an attractive 63.

 

Thanks for the comments.

 

[JOBESSI]

nice!

[relicsncoins]

I'm suprised that crecent toner didn't get a star.

 

JJ