1884-CC Morgan in GSA holder grade and will it *?

[coinsarefun]

What grade do you say and do you think this one will receive a star?

 

 

[relicsncoins]

There is a toning shadow under the date which leads me to believe NT. I believe it will grade and would grade MS63 with no star.

[Bruceswar]

There is a toning shadow under the date which leads me to believe NT. I believe it will grade and would grade MS63 with no star.

 

Being this is a GSA it has to be NT. Anyhow... I am in at MS 64

[relicsncoins]

There is a toning shadow under the date which leads me to believe NT. I believe it will grade and would grade MS63 with no star.

 

Being this is a GSA it has to be NT. Anyhow... I am in at MS 64

 

Those GSA cases are not air tight. A coin could probably be gassed in the holder.

[JOBESSI]

I think there are too many contact marks on the edge of the rainbow on the obv to go star. MS63 Max

[Bruceswar]

There is a toning shadow under the date which leads me to believe NT. I believe it will grade and would grade MS63 with no star.

 

Being this is a GSA it has to be NT. Anyhow... I am in at MS 64

 

Those GSA cases are not air tight. A coin could probably be gassed in the holder.

 

It could happen but just highly unlikely.

[C.I.]

Contact marks in the field should limit grade. Several of the hits on the devise are more than grazes and have moved metal. Very good strike. MS63 no star.

 

Chet

[Coindude]

I say 63 star!

[James_OldeTowne]

Being a GSA, it's a solid MS-64, and I think odds are better than 50-50 that it gets a star.

[bsshog40]

I'd say with the scrapes and nics that this thing gets no higher than a 63. I think the colors are just too common to get a star for it.

[rrantique]

There is a toning shadow under the date which leads me to believe NT. I believe it will grade and would grade MS63 with no star.

 

Being this is a GSA it has to be NT. Anyhow... I am in at MS 64

 

(thumbs u

[cpm9ball]

I'm with James!

 

Chris

[Mark T]

I agree with James that this coin has a 50/50 shot at getting a star.

This is a coin I would have in my collection – I love the obverse tone.

Grade – MS 63 or 64.

 

[Kamillion]

that is a sweet looking morgan

[Kurtdog]

Technical MS-63 and the market may bump it up for the color. Nice GSA.

[Walkerfan]

MS 64 with a shot at a star. Could go either way but definitely a reasonable chance. IMHO.

[coinman_23885]

What grade do you say and do you think this one will receive a star?

 

 

 

To me the toning looks questionable, but given that the coin is in a GSA holder, I'm guessing that is the photograph. I'll say MS64, no star. The toning is too blotchy for a star in my opinion.

[Kurtdog]

The rim-hit is the question on this one. Technically, however, I have to concede, she's right in there, with the MS-65s. Let NGC figure out the market grade, they have the broader knowledge base to determine that.

 

PS: I think it's great, BTW, that NGC keeps these in the GSA holders. It's pretentious, I think, to even think of cracking these out, just to grade them. There's no good reason for it outside of brand-narcissim. JMHO...

[coinsarefun]

Thanks everyone for your comments. I will let you know what it grades.

And get some professional images