1958 Proof Jefferson Nickel - Grade REVEALED

[ModCrewman-migration]

Hello all. Noob over here after posting ATS for a couple years. I picked this one up for a bargain price and have recently submitted it ATS, and while impatiently awaiting the results am curious what your grade opinions might be?

 

 

PCGS ruled PR68 CAM today...looks like the board was pretty close.

[James_OldeTowne]

I think it will not cam, thus "other".

[bsshog40]

I agree. Looks like Cameo on the Rev but none on the Obv. Still think it may go around PF66-67 tho'.

[michael]

welcome to the boards

 

i think at least 68 cam with the reverse being cameo+

[johnny9434]

the reverse looks good. somethings odd on the obverse thou. jmo

[robec1347]

It looks close to cameo, but the obverse looks like one large frost break from the chin to head. I voted "other".

[ModCrewman-migration]

Got the grades today...any new opinions?

[ModCrewman-migration]

It seems that perhaps the poll has run it's course.

 

PCGS's verdict was PR68 CAM...not the DCAM I was hoping for, but not a bad grade at all.

[Chris1976]

At least I was close, I guessed PR67 CAM

[bsshog40]

It seems that perhaps the poll has run it's course.

 

PCGS's verdict was PR68 CAM...not the DCAM I was hoping for, but not a bad grade at all.

Nice grade. It just goes to show how pictures just cannot bring out the true looks of a coin.