Show me your Non Star Designated coins that should have a star!!!

[fishfinder]

I like the colors on that nick PC. It reminds of this raw proof. I suppose it might star if questionable toning did not come into play.

[James_OldeTowne]

TTT

[Hard Times]

Got this one from Brandon Kelley back in the Anaconda days............

 

[robec1347]

[dean1345]

1899 PF65BN and this deserved the *

 

[The Penny Lady]

I haven't tried to get this one into a STAR holder, but I think it deserves it, and perhaps even a PLUS - what do you think?

 

 

 

[Coindude]

Charmy, that coin is gorgeous and is an absolute WOW coin! That's what I thought before I saw the date, and now it's a double WOW coin!!

[The Penny Lady]

Here's another one that I think deserves a STAR....

 

[dean1345]

Charmy.......Luv your Indians.

[erwindoc]

Ive got three that deserve it in my opinion. One, the 58D has been to NGC twice. The 61D same thing. I think the speckled toning areas are keeping it down. The 56 has only been once, when it was originally graded, so it may be due for another trip, but the reverse is a little too dark for them I think.

 

58D MS67FT

 

61D MS67FT

 

56P MS67FT