Guess the Commem grades ( grades posted in original post)

[MJ]

All the coins below are NGC with the exception of the PCGS Oregon

 

guess what the graders graded these

 

For those of you who have seen these............shhh

 

a) Maine via Shepherd/Gale......................66 NGC (old pre star holder)

b) Carver ex Bingham aka monsterman........66*

c) Rhode Island .........................................66 PL

d) Hudson..................................................66 *

e) BTW......................................................66*

f) Pilgrim via Brandon Kelley.........................66*

g) Oregon via Shepherd................................67 ( has a 67 NGC insert as well)

h) New Rochelle ex Porter ex Bingham.........67*

 

[SkyMan]

Wowsers! Those be some bad commems. That Hudson is a toughie to find nicely toned. I particularly like the tab toning on the New Rochelle.

[physics-fan3.14]

Hey, how do you expect us to give you grades with crappy pictures like that

 

66*

65

67

66

65

67

66

66

 

Amazing set of coins.

[robec1347]

That is one great group of commems. I normally don't care for the Washington-Carver, but I'll make a definite exception on this one.

[Dene]

66

66

66

65

66

67

66

66

Tough call on them all. All are really great looking coins.

[leeg]

All SUPER NICE examples!!!!!!!!

 

[Schatzy]

66

65

66

66

65

67

66

66

[Dwaine]

WOW, those are great coins and great pictures. I am going to assume most are in the 66 to 67 range but to put grades on each coin I am not going to attempt.

 

I am quite jealous of these coins as I just started a commem set and would love to have all of them.

 

[Coindude]

Wow, I normally don't care for the New Rochelle's at all, but that one.... man I really really like that one.

[bsshog40]

I like them all. My favorite is the Oregon!!

[MJ]

grades in original post. thanks for the guesses. MJ

[physics-fan3.14]

Wow, those are even nicer than I thought. Very cool!