"Centennial Dollar" follow-up. FYI
May 5 1876
Hon. James Pollock
Sir
I send you sketches of the New Dollar as proposed and described in the directions you did me the
honor to hand to me.
In No. 1 I have shown [sic] a reverse, having the number of stars, wreath, and denomination
only, omitting all inscriptions. And of course omitting the stars on its obverse as we have them
here, viz in this drawing.
In No. 2 I have shewn [sic] the inscription of “First Centennial of American Independence” and
suggested how the motto “In God We Trust” could be inserted on either face of the coin.
In No. 3 I have simply shewn [sic] for example how the stars would look in the outer
circumference of the letters United States of America as in this No. 3 or inside the words as in
No. 2.
I wish to remark that if we use the motto “First Centennial of American Independence” it would
involve making a new die when no longer appropriate. Also by taking up some of our space,
prevents the full display of a wreath, as shown in drawing No. 1.
In No. 4 I shew [sic] a wreath and stars on the reverse, and the Head of Liberty and appropriate
mottos on the obverse.
I am Sir
Very respectfully Yours,
William Barber
May 6, 1876
Hon. H.R. Linderman
Director of the Mint
Washington,
D.C.
Sir
In compliance with your request of the 1st inst., our Engraver, Mr. Barber, has prepared, and I
herewith enclose for your consideration, four designs for a new silver dollar, for the Centennial
and subsequent years.
My own decided preference for the Centennial dollar is the design on card No. 2 and for the
subsequent years the design on card No. 4. The Engraver is in entire accord with me in this
choice. The designs explain themselves, and show how very happily they can be adapted to the
proposed new coin, without crowding or clumsiness. No. 2 gives with ease and neatness the
essential and very desirable inscription “First Centennial of American Independence,” and No. 4
shows how very readily and appropriately for future years the circle of stars can be transferred
from the obverse to the reverse, in lieu of the Centennial inscription, and yet preserve the general
unity of the successive issues of the new dollar, while still leaving the Centennial dollar a
distinctive coin by itself.
[May 8, 1876
I think the idea of using “First Centennial of American Independence” on the regular issue had
better be abandoned, and strike a specimen (No. 3) using the Regular Obverse for that purpose.
As the piece could be struck on the large Press, you could readily strike any number required. I
shall be glad to discuss the matter fully on Thursday.
H.R. Linderman,
Director.