Which company graded this morgan ?

[dooly]

and do you think it is worth bidding on

 

[bsshog40]

ICG, they are a reputable company as far as I'm concerned.

ICG Coin

[CarolinaCollector]

Ditto.

[SuperDave]

Sight-unseen (which is essentially what photos of that quality qualify the coin as), I'd likely not exceed 63 money for it. However, ICG is to be trusted to determine authenticity.

[jesbroken]

I have several of their coins-mostly dimes, but no problem with their grading nor resaleablility.

Jim

[lsica]

I'd likely not exceed 63 money for it. However, ICG is to be trusted to determine authenticity.

 

For what it's worth, ICG 83-O's in MS64 currently Blue Sheet more than either PCGS or NGC ones ($46 vs $41)

[Mirrored Morgan]

Looks like a nice 83-O to me.

[TomB]

I try to limit my bidding activities to those coins that I can actually see clearly in the provided images.

[relicsncoins]

I've cracked and sent 3 ICG coins to NGC and these were my results.

 

2 ICG 64 Morgans.......... 1 came back a 63 and one came back a 64star.

 

1 1859 AU55 Indian Head Cent NGC BB for cleaning. (I think they got this one wrong) Rick Snow looked at the coin in the ICG holder and mentioned nothing about cleaning.

 

JJ

[Zoins]

1 1859 AU55 Indian Head Cent NGC BB for cleaning. (I think they got this one wrong) Rick Snow looked at the coin in the ICG holder and mentioned nothing about cleaning.

You might try sending that one to PCGS. There was a recent thread ATS about PCGS slabbing a NGC BB Cleaned buffalo nickel.

[MunkyMan95]

1 1859 AU55 Indian Head Cent NGC BB for cleaning. (I think they got this one wrong) Rick Snow looked at the coin in the ICG holder and mentioned nothing about cleaning.

You might try sending that one to PCGS. There was a recent thread ATS about PCGS slabbing a NGC BB Cleaned buffalo nickel.

 

Does that make NGC too harsh, or PCGS too liberal?