What does the grading designation "Questionable Color" mean specifically? 1 1

[Origami Master]

What does the grading designation "Questionable Color" mean?

[Hoghead515]

Usually means they think it may be artifically toned. 

[Origami Master]

Does this look artificially toned?

[Origami Master]

Does this look artificially toned?

[The Neophyte Numismatist]

It is impossible to tell from the photos.  There is too much glare to really see the coin surfaces.  And, we would need to see the reverse also.

[Origami Master]

Ok, well I am unable to take sufficient pictures at the present time so... oh well.

[Sandon]

   PCGS uses this description to designate likely artificial toning, which is created by "coin doctors" in an attempt to increase the coin's value to collectors who like toned coins or to disguise "cleaning" or other problems.  I believe that NGC designates such pieces as "artificially toned" or "altered color".  It is sometimes controversial whether the toning on a particular coin is natural or artificial.

   The coloration on your 1909 Lincoln cent does not appear to be original.  It should be orange, not pinkish as it appears in the photo.  Compare it to the accompanying photo of a 1909 V.D.B. graded MS 65 RD.

[Origami Master]

Ok thanks for the info

[Oldhoopster]

Agree with the others.  I don't believe your coin toned naturally.