1903 o morgan. whats your best price? 0

[Bink2090]

What would be your best guess on the value? cant find any comps on the auctions or ebay.

[B.C]

Gosh I think that one would be what ever someone is willing to pay for a damaged coin that looks nice to fill a hole 

[Bink2090]

yea. Im wndering if it would be better to crack it out and sell to dealer.

[B.C]

Crack it out and hope they don't notice the cleaning  hope they can pass it off as something it isn't I'm sure it happens but I'm sure we would all hate to have it happen to ourselves 

[B.C]

It is a nice coin I think someone needing it could look past the cleaning you might be surprised the price in a setting like eBay 

[Bink2090]

3 minutes ago, B.C said:

Crack it out and hope they don't notice the cleaning  hope they can pass it off as something it isn't I'm sure it happens but I'm sure we would all hate to have it happen to ourselves 

I actually showed it to 3 different coin dealers before I sent it off. they all offered $400-$500 for it and none of them thought it was cleaned.[ or at least never said as much] so I was a little surprised that it came back details.

[Bink2090]

thinking about possibly having pcgs take a look.

[Six Mile Rick]

5 minutes ago, Bink2090 said:

I actually showed it to 3 different coin dealers before I sent it off. they all offered $400-$500 for it and none of them thought it was cleaned.[ or at least never said as much] so I was a little surprised that it came back details.

Pop that puppy out and take it back to the dealer that offered you $400.

[Bink2090]

1 minute ago, Six Mile Rick said:

Pop that puppy out and take it back to the dealer that offered you $400.

I would feel guilty. but they are professionals. that's the only reason I had it graded. I was afraid they were trying to rip me off.lol

[Six Mile Rick]

Rotate it in the light and learn what your grading mistake looks like so you can do better next go around. I have done it too on Morgans but --- Cleaned is cleaned and you can't make it go away.

[kbbpll]

1 hour ago, Bink2090 said:

cant find any comps

https://www.ngccoin.com/coin-explorer/morgan-dollars-1878-1921-pscid-49/1903-o-1-ms-coinid-17286

Look under MS60 - 3 out of 4 are details/genuine. "View All" shows a bunch more. $305-408.