GTG 1911 5c (REVEALED)

[coinman_23885]

[MarkFeld]

66

[Danye West]

65

[Mark T]

Not really familiar with grading these so I will just agree with Mark Feld at 66 !

[MarkFeld]

65

 

I don't know how the coin grades, but based on the images (which is all we have to go by) 65 is too low. The color and luster are fine, the surfaces look to be exceptionally clean and the areas of soft strike are acceptable at the 66 and 66+ grade levels, if not higher.

[Nutmeg Coin]

Around 64. Too many scattered marks to go gem or higher.

[Raisethis2]

Ms 66 seems about right to me.

 

A very nice coin IMO.

[KMAG100]

I agree with most at 66

[Danye West]

65

 

I don't know how the coin grades, but based on the images (which is all we have to go by) 65 is too low. The color and luster are fine, the surfaces look to be exceptionally clean and the areas of soft strike are acceptable at the 66 and 66+ grade levels, if not higher.

 

I'm very suspicious of the high points on the cheek. It looks a bit scratched up there, and the photo could be hiding quite a bit.

I saturated it more so you can see what I'm seeing better.

 

Could be totally wrong though.

[Walkerfan]

Can't see any luster from those photos.

 

I see a contact abrasion right in front of Liberty's chin.

 

Strike is just decent and surfaces are otherwise smooth.

 

I wouldn't be surprised at 66 but certainly no higher.

[brg5658]

I'm with the 65 camp.

[coinman_23885]

Thank you to everyone for participating.