Your thoughts on these CC Morgans

[Coindude]

They aren't in the greatest shape, they both have rim bruising. Please give me your thoughts mainly on how much you think they're worth.

 

 

[MarkVIIIMarc]

I am new at this but I would like to put in my guess before those in the know do. To see if I am off base.

 

http://www.coinstudy.com/morgan-silver-dollar-values.html This site is what I am largely basing my opinion on.

 

I believe even with the denting the 1890 has good lines and comes in at the bottom of "good". On ebay these do seem to bounce around the upper $20's in better condition so I believe low $20's?

 

That 1893cc must be a desirable coin! IMHO (and uneducated) opinion it is on the plus end of fine. I base this on the eye detail left and the slight loss of detail on the flowers above the ear. Fine says $238, Extremely Fine $1174. WHAT A DIFFERENCE! So I have no clue on the value but it might be worth grading.

 

Now to let the others educate me.

 

[mtnstyne]

1890 CC: 75-95 range

1893 CC: This one is much tougher, strange discoloration around the coin, looks like some pitting on the cheek?, anyway I would say low end $200.

[coinman_23885]

1890 CC: 75-95 range

1893 CC: This one is much tougher, strange discoloration around the coin, looks like some pitting on the cheek?, anyway I would say low end $200.

 

I have refrained from commenting on this thread because I don't regularly trade Morgan Dollars in circulated grades, but this poster's valuation sounds reasonable to me. If anything, I could see the 1893 CC selling for a bit more, maybe $50 or so more on a good day for whatever it is worth.

[mtnstyne]

1890 CC: 75-95 range

1893 CC: This one is much tougher, strange discoloration around the coin, looks like some pitting on the cheek?, anyway I would say low end $200.

 

I have refrained from commenting on this thread because I don't regularly trade Morgan Dollars in circulated grades, but this poster's valuation sounds reasonable to me. If anything, I could see the 1893 CC selling for a bit more, maybe $50 or so more on a good day for whatever it is worth.

 

I should clarify on the 93CC, by low end $200 I meant I can't see it going for less than $200 with some possible upside. With the pictures provided it's just very difficult to guess what the coin really looks like as far as the surfaces go.

[Coindude]

Thanks for the comments guys. These are not my coins. A lady called me, wanting to know the value of her coins. These were the only two that were not junk silver. I initially told her that I considered the 90 to be a $50 coin and the 93 a $100 coin. After rethinking my position I told her a few days ago that the 93 would be a $200 coin and no change on the 90. Now that I have received more comments I feel more comfortable about my pricing.

 

Thanks for the comments guys.

[MarkVIIIMarc]

Like I said, keep in mind my comments reflect my state of knowledge, a newb maybe bidding on ebay!