Star Worthy?

[mikew148]

I just picked up this 64D Washie. It's in a PCGS holder.

 

I'm not crazy about the dark stuff at 3 o'clock.

 

Would you/NGC consider giving this one a star?

 

[copper toning]

I doubt it. I do not care for the colors or pattern

[Walkerfan]

It's nice but not STAR nice IMHO.

[coinman_23885]

I don't think it will star.

[AHFreak]

I also do not think it is star worthy.

 

What is it graded? 64?

[TonerGuy]

Before I would say star / no star - what does the reverse look like ?

 

Nice coin though. Ive heard 64s are tough to find with nice color.

[physics-fan3.14]

I can't make any opinion without seeing the reverse.

 

However, the obverse alone just doesn't seem to have enough "pop" for a star. It is a very attractive coin, and I like the colors.... it just doesn't scream "star" to me. However, the star is a seemingly random thing, subject to the whims and fancies of the graders that day. I think it comes down to whether the graders had a bear claw or a strawberry pastry for breakfast that morning.

[jerseycat10]

Agree with others. Attractive, but not not star worthy.

[brg5658]

I can't make any opinion without seeing the reverse.

 

However, the obverse alone just doesn't seem to have enough "pop" for a star. It is a very attractive coin, and I like the colors.... it just doesn't scream "star" to me. However, the star is a seemingly random thing, subject to the whims and fancies of the graders that day. I think it comes down to whether the graders had a bear claw or a strawberry pastry for breakfast that morning.

 

 

...so true...

[mikew148]

I can't make any opinion without seeing the reverse.

 

However, the obverse alone just doesn't seem to have enough "pop" for a star. It is a very attractive coin, and I like the colors.... it just doesn't scream "star" to me. However, the star is a seemingly random thing, subject to the whims and fancies of the graders that day. I think it comes down to whether the graders had a bear claw or a strawberry pastry for breakfast that morning.

 

The reverse is 90% white with some scattered brown toning - nothing to help with a star designation.

 

This one likely just misses the cut

 

Thanks All!

[kryptonitecomics]

No star....

[Raisethis2]

I'd think if the picture is washed out just a little bit that it would indeed get the star. That however seems a bit to light.

[RWB]

It's an incredibly common coin with spotty tarnish....Maybe you should check with the famous "International Star Registry" for your star?

[coinman1794]

This type of color on a 1964 makes the coin something special, but the chance of a Star is small, because the toning scheme includes mottled dark spots.

 

It would also depend on what the reverse looks like.