1923-S Peace Dollar

[A.Phillips]

What grade will you give to that Peace Dollar? I am thinking about to submit it to NGC if necessary. I added 2 different pictures with 2 different lights of reverse.

 

 

 

 

[ldhair]

I'll guess 55 or 58.

[Raisethis2]

It looks MS 63 ish. to me.

 

[A.Phillips]

I'll guess 55 or 58.

 

I think it's above than MS60 because it shows more details than 55/58.

[zboyle04]

most likely 63 but shot at 64

[Coindude]

taking a closer look at the obverse the high point in the cheek and hair appear to have some rub. This could just be toning and I hope that's what it is.

 

AU58

[johnny9434]

ill give it a shot with a ms 64. fwiw

[yonico]

Might be the toning, but I see some light rub as well.

 

AU58

[slcoin]

I think it's MS, my guess is 62-63. Leaning towards 63.

[FishyOne]

She's a slider, could go as low as 55 or as high as 63. Nice color.

[Walkerfan]

AU 55-58.

 

I see what looks like rub to me on the hair and high cheek bone. .

[coinman_23885]

63 - I think the toning is throwing people off, making some perceive it as rub.

[jpcienkus]

Kenny, the abrupt absense of the toning on the hair and cheek definitely threw me off.

 

I'd guess MS63 max.

[ldhair]

What did it grade?

[$ilverHawk]

I'll guess 55 or 58.

 

+1 Very difficult to judge from pics. But there does seem to be high point wear areas.

 

I'm curious, why are you focusing on the reverse?

 

Carl

[A.Phillips]

What did it grade?

 

It was in ANACS MS62, I will submit the Peace Dollar to NGC soon though.

 

I'm curious, why are you focusing on the reverse?

 

I just shooting 2 pictures of reverse with 2 different direct lights, I don't know which one is better, that's all. I tried to do several different lights on obverse, but none of it are good except that one I had on first page.