1884 PR Cent

[AcesKings]

I just got this one at the Philadelphia show, and thought it was under graded. Graded by PCGS as a Proof/brown. What numerical grade do you think they gave it?

 

 

 

I can understand the brown designation because of the reverse color, holder is pretty scuffed up so its hard getting anything better than this......

[FishyOne]

Had you not said it looked under-graded I would have said 63 with a shot at 64.

 

If you think it is under-graded? I bet it's in a 62 holder and it would be one VERY nice 62.

[yonico]

Looks like a nice PR63

I'm assuming the X under A of states is on the plastic and not on the coin..

[BillJones]

By the photo I would go PR-63, Brown.

[Coindude]

I think 63 myself, mainly from the spot on the obverse. It looks like it has some excellent color especially on the obverse. A lot of green showing through on the one shot.

[AcesKings]

I'm assuming the X under A of states is on the plastic and not on the coin..

 

Yes, that's on the holder, the dot under the I and T is on the coin itself though. I thought when I seen it, it was an easy 63, POSSIBLY a 64 for how clean the Indians head is, this is what they gave it......

 

[Coindude]

I'd take that coin for 62 money any day of the week.

[FishyOne]

A very strong 62. You do have one that looks a point undergraded.

[AcesKings]

Thank you all for your opinions, its very greatly appreciated!!!

[Coinbuf]

The detail are better than the grade, but the spots on the obv are the grade limiter. I like coins like this graded correctly but look better.

[Kurtdog]

Yeah, that dot hurt her. It's like an eye magnet. She's easily a higher grade without it.

[johnny9434]

I'd take that coin for 62 money any day of the week.

+1

[Walkerfan]

I'm not bothered by the spot. It looks like a nice 63 to me.