WHAT TO DO? posted by Eagles-R-it

[CSJournals-migration]

ADVICE PLEASE, AGAIN.

 

When I renewed my NGC membership, I did so by upgrading to get the 5 free submissions. I did this knowing that I would indeed have five new coins to send. They are the 2013 reverse buffalo, 2013 W silver eagle set, and a yet unopened 2012 S silver eagle set.

What to do, the buffalo looks like a 69, the 2013 enhanced obverse has a scratch like image on it, more like a piece of fuzz got in there just as the press came together, and a bag like nick on the reverse. As I said, the 2012 S is unopened. I know the enhanced will be a 69 and I can buy them already certified for $69 so why waste my free ones eh? Or send them all in and see what comes up. I don't even know if I should send in any. I do have an unopened 2011 25th anniversary set in the closet I guess would work.

Any who, give me your thoughts fellow members both good bad and for my own stupidity let me have it. I wish I could just send the 2013 W back, but that costs more also and no knowing if they have more or not, and maybe if they did the replacement could be worse.

THANKS EVERYONE.

 

See more journals by Eagles-R-it

[Six Mile Rick]

You have a while so just wait till you have 5 that you will be pleased to send in.

[mt1missile-migration]

If there are scratches on the coins, send them back to the mint. They are still making both sets. They are not selling more but as per a conversation I had with the mint 2 days ago they are still sending out coins for the Eagle Set and the Buffalo. I'd get replacements for them ASAP.

[The Fielding Collection]

I agree with both you have time on your side so send in coins your happy with. As far as the coins you want to exchange I'd call the mint and then send them back if replacements are available. jmho.....Mike