Better pics of my next submission, 1959 mint set and 1958 5c

[djdilliodon]

Here are some better pics of a 1959 mint set I picked up that the coins toned nicely. It was housed in an after market snap lock holder with card board insert.

 

59 P mint franklin. Nice color for the date and looks to have a shot at ms65. They might 64 it though.

 

59 D mint franklin. This one has excellent color for the date and should get ms65*fbl.

 

59 P mint Washington. Super color but it may only go ms64 star:(.

 

59 D Washington. Obv IMO is 63, reverse is an easy 65 shot 66. My guess they will 64 it and give it the star.

 

59 D Roosevelt. Awesome color and IMO should go 67* shot FT. This is the nicest one I've seen for this date and mint mark!

 

1958 P Jefferson. I'm interested too hear what you all think of this one. I've had this coin raw now for 4 years and purchased it in a double mint set. Its the most colorful Jefferson I've personally seen but the color is so wild I never sent it in fear of it getting bagged. The coin is weakly struck and IMO is ms63. I'm gonna send it in and let ngc decide its fate.

 

[coinman101-migration]

Here are my opinions.

 

1) 1959 50c - MS-64

1959 Doubled Die Reverse (Breen 5251, FS-80) (Type 2 over 1)

 

2) 1959-D 50c - MS-65 FBL

 

3) 1959 25c - MS-65 (no star)

 

4) 1959-D PASS

 

5) 1959-D 10c - MS-67 FT

 

6) Bagged

 

Taylor

[djdilliodon]

Here are my opinions.

 

1) 1959 50c - MS-64

1959 Doubled Die Reverse (Breen 5251, FS-80) (Type 2 over 1)

 

2) 1959-D 50c - MS-65 FBL

 

3) 1959 25c - MS-65 (no star)

 

4) 1959-D PASS

 

5) 1959-D 10c - MS-67 FT

 

6) Bagged

 

Taylor

 

What's that double die worth and does ngc attribute it?

[coinman_23885]

1) MS65 (assuming the luster is all there)

2) MS65 no FBL - I see some weakness in the bell lines.

3) MS64* (shot MS65 if bumped up for color)

4) MS64* (I agree with your assessment about the split grade)

5)MS66 no FT (although the designation has not always been applied consistently so FT is a possibility)

6) Uncirculated details - environmental damage

[WoodenJefferson]

1958 Philadelphia Jefferson nickel, hard to believe the Mother Mint put this coin in their Mint Set as a representative of this year. I do believe the grading company will have to reject this particular coin as questionable...it may not even be market acceptable with hard core collectors. I like to find virtue in all coins, but this one scores low.

[coinman101-migration]

You can find that out in a few clicks by visiting the price guide.

Here are my opinions.

 

1) 1959 50c - MS-64

1959 Doubled Die Reverse (Breen 5251, FS-80) (Type 2 over 1)

 

2) 1959-D 50c - MS-65 FBL

 

3) 1959 25c - MS-65 (no star)

 

4) 1959-D PASS

 

5) 1959-D 10c - MS-67 FT

 

6) Bagged

 

Taylor

 

What's that double die worth and does ngc attribute it?

[RWB]

63

63

62

61

64

NG

 

[yonico]

My guesses

 

1. 59-P franklin MS65 no FBL

 

2. 59-D franklin MS65FBL

 

3. 59-P Washington MS64*

 

4. 59-D Washington MS64*

 

5. 59-D Roosevelt MS66* no FT

 

6. 59-P Jefferson UNC DETAILS

 

[Raisethis2]

 

 

1 64

2 65 *

3 64*

4 63

5 65 hits on foerhead and torch. Torch is not complete.

6 NG That color (even if your photography sucks) in not natural.

 

 

[djdilliodon]

Thanks so far for the input. I think ill be saving my submission fees on the Jefferson and putting the extra cash towards the variety plus to get the 59 franklin attributed as a DDR.

[coinman101-migration]

Thanks so far for the input. I think ill be saving my submission fees on the Jefferson and putting the extra cash towards the variety plus to get the 59 franklin attributed as a DDR.

You might do well on the DDR franklin. I am glad I noticed it.

[coinman1794]

Great color coins, but the 1959-D 25C is a most elusive issue to find with such hues. Amazing coin!

 

The 1959 DDR sells for about $60 in NGC MS64 and about $130 in NGC MS65. Yes, NGC does attribute this variety.

[yonico]

We have a 3rd 'coinman' now?

This is getting confusing

[Walkerfan]

63 or 64

65

65*

64*

67* FT

Details. If that doesn't have any rub that is one BAD strike.