GRADE POSTED: 1955 Washington Quarter, die polish and all!

[James_OldeTowne]

The images are fairly representative. Have at it!

 

 

[bsshog40]

Nice older proof there James. I'm not sure about the spotting tho', looks like quite a bit of it. If it were mine and raw, that thing would be takin a quick dip. I'm guessing about PF64-65.

[noow]

PF-65, Semi-Cam

[coinman_23885]

As you already know, it's impossible to see all hairlines in a photo of a proof coin. I'll guess PF66-PF67 from what I can see. You may make a CAM, but there is enough weakness on the eagle instead that I would award a star instead.

[noow]

PF64/65 actually, I'm in the middle.

Got a partial CAM

[e1cnr]

cleaned

 

I would have a difficult time convincing myself those were die polish lines at those locations - although with a loupe, I might be able to see them raised rather than indented

[noow]

Cleaned? I'll take a look

[Ryan S.]

Looks a little better than the ones from my old "Route (proof) 66 collection", but grading these can be tough for me. I'd give it a PF-66 CAM.

[brg5658]

I'll say PF66*. I'd be surprised if it got a Cam designation.

[Chris1976]

I'd say between PF65 to PF67 with a star, but I dont see it getting a CAM from the looks of the right side wing, but it could just be the way the picture was taken.

[Joe Swindell-migration]

PF66. Nice coin.

[johnny9434]

PF 65 maybe a 64

[Coindude]

PR 64, the spot on the obverse of such a nice coin with such nice mirrors would hold it back. The reverse prevents the cameo designation although the obverse shows some really nice frosting from what appears to be a repolish.

[physics-fan3.14]

65* - obverse has a nice repolished cameo, but the reverse just isn't strong enough.

[James_OldeTowne]

I'm a little iffy on the NGC grade myself. They called it.... (drumroll)....

 

PF-68 CAM!

 

Thanks for guessing, all!

 

 

[bsshog40]

Well I do have to add. I think the Cam part is close enough to be ok. If the spotting came after the slabbing, then ok. I don't think the die polish lines should effect anything but if the spotting was there when it was slabbed, I could not buy this coin, as is, as a PF68. jmo

[Coindude]

James, is it in an older slab? Can't have been graded in the last 4 years or so if it's Cam designated. The graders are much more strict now.

[James_OldeTowne]

The slab is of the generation just prior to the current EdgeView holders.