Any opinions on this SLQ ?

[messydesk]

Interesting to read these opinions, having seen the coin in hand. I'll only echo that it is a great coin.

[jom]

The super-large photos are cool, but really are hard to assess for eye-appeal.

 

Yeah, considering the original photo is larger than my screen.

 

jom

[relicsncoins]

Ok, what's the grade?

[Walkerfan]

It has dazzling color. Looks like AT LEAST an MS 64. I agree that the head is pretty full but may not receive that distinction. VERY SWEET coin from a series that I like just about as much as Walkers!

[noow]

GRADE???

[Elbesaar]

 

Patience... I'm still waiting for the owner of the 1919-S

to chime in.

 

Jom, I promise the holdered image is a lot smaller.

 

BTW - it was Messydesk's imaging that has been shown

on this 19-S. Nice job , huh ?

[BROADSTRUCK]

Here's messydesk's slab shots which shows the luster along with the assigned grade.

 

It was encapsulated before NGC was awarding stars.

 

[noow]

! MS63 ! Keep? Resubmit?

[Elbesaar]

[Elbesaar]

As they say... the Cat's out of the bag !!

 

 

Not one person guessed the correct grade !!

 

Everyone thought it was at least one point higher

and a few thought it was two points higher and a few

three points higher.

 

Its a fantastic coin. I'd resubmit it to get a higher grade or a Star at NGC.

 

 

[noow]

My first guess was 63- but then I saw many 65's.... Peer preasure!

I was looking at that slash across the cheek and carbon spots...

[noow]

!!! GOLD CAC STICKER? !!!

[brg5658]

!!! GOLD CAC STICKER? !!!

 

Sigh....keep going noow. If you post 2 replies for every other person's 1 reply, you will be to 800 posts by morning.

[BillJones]

Yes, if it's as nice as its picture, that one is a worthy of gold CAC sticker for sure.

[Elbesaar]

 

Thanks, BillJones, I value your opinion highly.

 

Thank you, noow, for your enthusiasm.

[Dudley the 1st]

I think NGC got this wrong to begin with, by at least two grades. Re-submit.

[noow]

!!! GOLD CAC STICKER? !!!

 

Sigh....keep going noow. If you post 2 replies for every other person's 1 reply, you will be to 800 posts by morning.

 

Looks like you got some "noow" math skils

[MarkInDavis-migration]

My guess was 64. I think it is attractive, but definitely don't see it as a 65 or 66.