NT or AT??

[Bruceswar]

What are your thoughts on this Morgan? Grade thoughts as well plz...

 

[bsshog40]

Boy Bruce, I've never been good at these unless it looks very obvious. I'm gonna guess AT as it looks like it has a couple burn spots to me. It's also hard for me to grade this by the pics. The Obv looks to have nice detail but the Rev. is either a weak strike effecting not only the eagle breast but also looks to be weak in the leg details also. Would guess maybe MS63 even with the rim dings below the D in dollar.

[coinman1794]

I would guess original, not knowing the coins history. 1904-O in particular sometimes tones in these exact colors.

[braddick]

I like it as NT. The reeding mark on the check keep it out of the GEM classification. With luster, that color should bounce.

[Dcoin]

What are the chances that both the OBV and REV have the exact same toning pattern?

 

All I would go with NT but the question above would indicate caution.

[harvey8542]

I'll go with Nt and say I like it (thumbs u

[kryptonitecomics]

Pretty difficult to tell with that image.....this one really would have to bee seen in hand to judge color and luster etc. My first thought was AT but I would be the first to admit that its completely impossible to make an accurate assessment from what I am seeing

[michael]

hard to tell either way from the photos

 

 

but just from the photos ............................ AT to me

[Bruceswar]

Coin has nice luster and we must remember New Orleans is not known for well struck coins.

[rrantique]

NT and MS-63. (thumbs u

[jgrinz]

The 'questionable' toning is hiding a lot of the details if in fact they are there.

Looks AU to me in that picture.

 

[Bruceswar]

The 'questionable' toning is hiding a lot of the details if in fact they are there.

Looks AU to me in that picture.

 

Coin is Full UNC. Weak Strike.

[James_OldeTowne]

I'd be at MS-63 and acceptable toning.

[just carl]

NT and MS-63. (thumbs u

I agree with that completely. The way the colors are splatered around it appears NT. Usually an AT has more steady color dispursement.

Regardless, just what is AT and NT anyway? If you left a coin on a window sill for a year or so and did it purposely is that AT? If you did it and just forgot it was there and it toned, does that now make it NT? In most instances AT or NT is way to debatable.

[carson city]

Beautiful AT, try to get it into an NGC holder.

[rrantique]

Here is another with similar toning.

Certainly not as good a photo as Bruce.

 

 

[SkyMan]

Looks NT envelope toned to me.