The true story behind the reverse design of Ikes and SBAs.

[SkyMan]

As I'm sure you are all aware the reverse design of the Eisenhower and Susan B. Anthony is a modified version of the Apollo 11 emblem. Here is how the design came about. The excerpt is from Michael Collins book, "Carrying the Fire: An Astronaut's Journey". For those of you that like space related stuff I certainly recommend the book. It is both informative and quite amusing in parts.

 

"There were also a variety of non-technical chores, such as thinking up names for our spacecraft and designing a mission emblem. We felt Apollo 11 was no ordinary flight, and we wanted no ordinary design, yet we were not professional designers. NASA offered us no help along these lines (wisely, I think). On Gemini 10 (a flight Collins was on), which in my view has the best-looking insignia of the Gemini series, artistic Barbara Young had developed one of John's ideas and come up with a graceful design, an aerodynamic X devoid of names and machines. This was the approach we wanted to take on Apollo 11. We wanted to keep our three names off it because we wanted the design to be representative of everyone who had worked toward a lunar landing, and there were thousands whoe could take a proprietary interest in it, yet who would never see their names woven into the fabric of a patch. Further, we wanted the design to be symbolic rather than explicit. On Apollo 7, Wally's patch showed the earth and an orbiting CSM trailing fire. On 9 McDivitt produced a Saturn V, a CSM, and an LM. Apollo 10's was even busier. Apollo 8's was closer to our way of thinking, showing a figure eight looping around earth and moon, on a command-module-shaped patch, but it had, like all the rest, three names printed on it. We needed something simpler, yet something which unmistakeably said peaceful lunar landing by the United States. Jim Lovell, Neil's back-up, introduced an American eagle into the conversation. Of course! What better symbol - eagles landed, didn't they? At home I skimmed through my library and finally found what I wanted in a National Geographic book on birds: a bald eagle, landing gear extended, wings partially folded, coming in for a landing. I traced it on a piece of tissue paper and sketched in an oblique view of a pockmarked lunar surface.

 

Thus the Apollo 11 patch was born, although it had a long way to go before final approval. I added a small earth in the background and drew the sunshine coming from the wrong direction, so that to this day our official insignia shows the earth over the lunar horizon like this (a drawing of a clear circle with from 7 to 11 o'clock darkened) when it should really look like (a drawing of a clear circle with from 4 to 8 o'clock darkened). I also penciled an APOLLO around the top of my circular design and ELEVEN around the bottom. Neil didn't like the ELEVEN because it wouldn't be understandable to foreigners, so after trying XI and 11, we settled on the latter and put APOLLO 11 around the top. One day outside the simulator I was describing my efforts to Jim Lovell, and he and I both agreed that the eagle alone really didn't convey the entire message we wanted. The Americans were about to land, but so what? Tom Wilson, our computer expert and simulator instructor, overheard us and piped up, Why not an olive branch as a symbol of our peaceful expedition? Beautiful! Where do eagles carry olive branches? In their beaks, naturally. So I sketched one in, and after a few discussions with Neil and Buzz over color schemes, we were ready to go to press. The sky would be black, not blue, but absolute black, as in the real case. The eagle would be eagle-colored, the moon moon-colored, as described by Apollo 8, and the earth also, so all we had left to play with, really, were the colors of the border and the lettering. We picked blue and gold, and then we had an illustrator at MSC do the artwork for us. We photographed his finished design and sent a copy through channels to Washington for approval. Washington usually rubber-stamped everything. Only this time they didn't, and our design came back disapproved. The reason? The eagle's landing gear, powerful talons extended stiffly below him, was unacceptable. It was too hostile, too warlike; it made the eagle appear to be swooping down on the moon in a very menacing fashion, according to Bob Gilruth. What to do? A gear-up approach was unthinkable to this pilot who had woken up more than once with cold sweats over a dreamed wheels-up landing. Perhaps the talons could be relaxed and softened a bit, made limp like a receiving-line handshake. Then someone had a brainstorm: just transfer the olive branch from beak to claw and all menace disappeared. The eagle looked slightly uncomfortable in the new version, clutching his branches tightly with both feet, but we resubmitted it anyway, and it greased on through channels and won final approval.

 

Years later the eagle still pops out at me from unfamiliar places, and the design has even found its way onto the reverse side of the part-silver (this book was copyrighted in 1974) Eisenhower dollar. This coin was issued during John Connally's short stint as Secretary of the Treasury, and he was kind enough to pen me a short note in August 1971 stating, among other things: '... the design on the reverse is a rendering of the Apollo 11 insignia'. As if I didn't know. The 'designer' of the coin's eagle told the press that it was a 'happy' eagle, but I don't know, it still looked uncomfortable to me. I just hoped it dropped that olive branch before landing."

[ibyandsellsmith]

Pictures would make that a little more interesting to read, for the laming man.

[rbrown4]

Very interesting story Sy, thanks for providing it.

 

Rey

[EZ_E]

Great story!

[bsshog40]

Nice story Sky. My wife is suppose to be a distand cousin to Susan B Anthony somewhere down the line. I got her a nice uncir one in a necklace a couple years back.

[jesbroken]

Thanks, Sy. What an interesting story. It will not be forgotten, whenever looking at a SBA or an Ike I will think of it. Great job.

 

[ldhair]

(thumbs u

[rbrown4]

I hope you don't mind Sy, but this SBA reverse has some natural gold toning which somehow peaks my interest. I only own three of these coins, but this makes this one worthwhile.

 

Rey

 

[bsshog40]

I have a Dansco of these Rey. I'm still 5 short tho'.I still have to get the proofs for 79', 80, & 81'. I will probably have to skip the type two's for 79' and 81' tho'. Those seem to be kind of high. None of them have toned tho'.

[rbrown4]

I have the 79, 79 S, 80 S and 81 S, let me know if you are interested. I am not looking to hold on to them. Trade, etc. whatever.

 

Rey

 

 

[bsshog40]

Are the S's the proofs Rey, or uncirculateds. I have the S uncircs but need the S proofs.

[SkyMan]

Glad you folks like the story. History like this just fascinates me. Here's my two type coins, a 77 Ike and a 79 SBA:

 

[bsshog40]

Here's my 99' proof!