1846 Seated Liberty Dollar for DANSCO 7070, Care to grade and comment?

[comicAL]

Hi, Everyone

 

I recently picked up this 1846 Seated Liberty Dollar for my DANSCO 7070 Type Coin Set. It has been certified by a TPG firm. If you like to test your grading skills from pictures and/or comment on the coin be my guest!

 

AAJ

 

[MunkyMan95]

It has been certified by a TPG firm.

 

It's certified by ANACS! What do I win?

[WoodenJefferson]

That little raised triangular diamond on the back of the slab gave the ANACS holder away...cheater!

 

I shall comment on the coin when I get back...gotta go!

[123cents]

Nice and crusty. I'll guess EF-45.

[MBA101]

I am going to say a nifty au-50.

 

Awesome coin!

[rrantique]

EF-45 nice coin Al

[Dwaine]

Not sure of the grade but a very nice pickup.

[MikeInFL]

Crusty XF 40 is my guess, but I could truly care less about the TPG grade as that coin is gorgeous regardless. I am jealous.

 

Congrats on your NEWP...Mike

[comicAL]

Hi, MunkyMan95

 

"It's certified by ANACS! What do I win?"

 

A hearty monkey hand shake!

 

AAJ

[Prethen]

I love it. It looks a lot like my 1847.

[TomB]

I love it! It is a really nice looking coin that is obviously graded by ANACS and that I would grade as EF40.

[Tradedollarnut]

AU55

[WoodenJefferson]

That coin has some masculine rims on the reverse...good and stout, just as tough as the Americans were in 1846.

 

I like the natural patina and the very small amount of circulation that this particualr coin has seen. It has been well cared for since...you must be proud to be the present owner.

 

XF-45

[ibyandsellsmith]

Real grade XF-45/ Anacs grade AU-59.

[SkyMan]

A very attractive coin!

[chinook]

xf-45

[jesbroken]

Beautiful patina, very original. Solid AU 50. Very nice PU. Great addition.

[CarolinaCollector]

I think this coin is much nicer than an XF...

 

I'll guess AU-58, but it could be mint state as I can't detect wear on the high points.

[RUSS BEGA]

Real grade XF-45/ Anacs grade AU-59.

 

 

I take it you are not a big fan of ANACS?

[AU58WALKERS-migration]

EF 45

[James_OldeTowne]

VERY sweet! I love the coin, especially for an album typeset! I'm at EF-45 on this one.

[CoinAddict]

Gorgeous coin. Definitely a keeper.

[bsshog40]

very nice original coin. I would venture to guess EF.

[MikeKing]

Lovely, and hard to find so nice, seated dollar. I'd grade it XF40.

[construct]

EF-45.

[stev32k]

That is exactly the look I like for my 7070. If you decide to upgrade that coin let me know - I'm a buyer. As for grade XF45 - AU55 (that's the best I can do).

[toyonakataro]

Nice looking coin

 

EF45 is my guess, but I won't be surprised if the answer is AU50.

[comicAL]

Hi, Everyone

 

First, thank you all for the kind words and grading of my 1846 SLD.

It looks like there was a range of EF 40 to AU 58, MikeInFL was the first to grade it the same way as ANACS, EF 40.

 

I have mentioned in other threads on this forum that I enjoy hunting for the smaller green worded ANACS slabs as I believe many are conservatively graded. Our guessing the grade from pictures in this thread and others of mine seems to support this idea.

 

When I saw this coin I graded it as a EF 45.

It will fit just nicely in my DANSCO 7070 Type Set Album!

 

AAJ

 

[BillJones]

AU sharpness, but no luster and totally natural.

 

I've seen these from time to time and they nice coins. They are easy to sell at the right levels, buy you won't hit any homeruns with them.

[James_OldeTowne]

I like it very much, especially at that grade!