1911-D St Gaudens PCGS MS65

[IlikeZARcoins]

PCGS price guide values this at $2,000.

 

My price is $1,925:

 

 

[IlikeZARcoins]

What would people pay for this coin ?

 

Remember that it is a scan so it doesn't reflect the true luster of the coin.

 

I collect Darkside coins so I don't follow US coin trends.

 

TIA

[jgrinz]

U R WAY over priced as is PCGS 's price guide ..

 

1911-D $20 St Gaudens PCGS MS65

Buy Now at $1,435.00

 

Buy Now Coin

[IlikeZARcoins]

Wow - that is some discreptancy alright.

 

Why is PCGS so wrong ?

[jgrinz]

They make there own pricing _ Kind of a Conflict of interest in thier favor. _

NGC refuses to valuate thier coins in house they use numismedia, an external source for thier pricing. PCGS prices are kind of a joke - rule of thumb is like use 65-70 percent of the figure they say and you get a closer figure to the real world pricing.

I would be intersted but I do not want to insult you with what I think it is worth and pay.

[IlikeZARcoins]

Oh that is OK. You'd get them cheaper on the Bay of E by the looks of it. I purchased mine for just a bit more then they are listed for in your link.

 

I thought that they had appreciated quite a bit when I looked at the PCGS price list hence I thought of selling it as it isn't part of my core collection. Guess I'll hang on to it a bit longer now.

 

Thanks for the head up about the PCGS price list.

[Doogy]

Marcel,

 

the CCDN (often seen as the most accurate pricing for US coins, as it comes out weekly) lists this year/date/condition as $ 1,120.00 Saints are pretty weak in price right now, as everyone is still going nuts for silly Buffalo gold and AGE bullion *spoon*. i'd hang onto it.

 

Doug

[IlikeZARcoins]

Thanks Doug,

 

Yes I will hang onto the St Gaudens after reading all the current market info on it.

 

The US price guides and what have you are basically useless for me unless I happen to stumble onto them on the net. As you know my collection is 99.99% Darkside in fact I have the above coin and an 1908 Indian Head $2.50 in MS64 ( I think that grades right ) which are the only US coins that I have. I used to follow PCGS guides but I'll pass on them after reading all the above.

[jgrinz]

Marcel,

 

the CCDN (often seen as the most accurate pricing for US coins, as it comes out weekly) lists this year/date/condition as $ 1,120.00 Saints are pretty weak in price right now, as everyone is still going nuts for silly Buffalo gold and AGE bullion *spoon*. i'd hang onto it.

 

Doug

 

hehe I at least was gonna offer him 1200

[Doogy]

Marcel,

 

the CCDN (often seen as the most accurate pricing for US coins, as it comes out weekly) lists this year/date/condition as $ 1,120.00 Saints are pretty weak in price right now, as everyone is still going nuts for silly Buffalo gold and AGE bullion *spoon*. i'd hang onto it.

 

Doug

 

hehe I at least was gonna offer him 1200

 

yeah, I don't know anyone that really uses the PCGS price guide as a true estimate of a coin's "value". Their numbers are generally inflated a good deal. I subscribe to the CCDN quite often (it runs like $4 a week), so if you need a US price, feel free to PM me.