Scores are Unrealistic - 1964 Proof Set -

[jgrinz]

Scores are Unrealistic - 1964 Proof Set -

 

Slot Description Certification Graded By Grade Score Updated NumisMedia Value*

1C 2511513-008 NGC PF 69 RDC 6 11/29/2006 $62.50

5C 2511513-009 NGC PF 69 CA 24 11/29/2006 $56.25

10C 2511513-010 NGC PF 69 CA 6 11/29/2006 No Price**

25C 2511513-007 NGC PF 69 CA 37 11/29/2006 $80.00

50C 2511513-011 NGC PF 69 CA 106 11/29/2006 $115.00

 

 

Please repair

[MunkyMan95]

6 points for the cent, and the dime?

[jgrinz]

The pricing is unrealistic too ... Go try and find any one of these in the grades that are posted ..

[EZ_E]

See Chad's sigline for those responsible for the arbitrary registry point system and for Numismedia's pricing structure.

[MunkyMan95]

[DC Dawg]

There is a link on the scores page to request a review. You can press the link and the system will send a page where you can enter your concerns. I just did that and was successful--not as successful as I would have like to have been, but it was better than 3 points for something like a PF69DCAM!

 

Scott

[dleonard-3]

I found that the score for a 1963 cent in MS67 is only 237 (with only 5 existing). I have a 1963 MS67 Dime in the same set that scores 437 (with 218 existing). Also, a 1963-D Half Dollar in MS66 FBL has a population of 16 (more than three times the population of the penny) and a score of 1928 which seems right to me.

 

Why is the score for the 1963 MS67 cent so low? Especially considering the population and value.

[zrlevin]

Maybe if you post this three or four more times, someone will listen.

[dleonard-3]

Persistence might pay off. I've got nothing better to do than post this over and over again.

[zrlevin]

Just be careful, Arch may get annoyed and lower the values of all of your coins to six.

[dleonard-3]

Arch claims he's not the one in charge of those decisions, so HA, HA, NANNY, NANNY.

 

On a related note; I did notice that the value for a 1963-D Half Dollar in MS66FBL just had the score change from 1928 to 2302. That's more than the entire set scores in TOP POP. Go figure.