Is the Rim Nick on this Rainbow Morgan Large enough to cause a No Grade?

[TonedCoinTrader]

In your opinion, is the Rim Nick on this Rainbow Morgan Large enough to cause a No Grade?

 

 

[Bruceswar]

I think it would grade, but thats just me

[kryptonitecomics]

I am pretty confident it would grade....I sent in a dime with a few rim nicks and it graded 66

[michael]

if i was at pcgs i would not grade it

 

no way this kills the coin for me this rim gouge it is not a rim nick

 

i think with pcgs you got a 50/50 chance but i would not grade this coin at all if i was at pcgs

 

this does not make it a bad coin though

 

more than likely ngc will grade this coin

[michael]

if the coin gets graded there will be an unlucky buyer that when he goes to sell this coin he will encounter much buyer resistance as it is is huge BUT coin

 

this coin is okie nothjing special BUT it has that rim gouge

[James_OldeTowne]

NGC, PCGS and ANACS would grade this coin, but I bet it would cost 1/2 point in the overall grading formula. Frankly, the PCGS inner ring will practically hide most of the rim nick, and if the coins is appropriately "net-graded" down, it will appear to be very "PQ" since the nick won't be apparent.

 

It is easier to see rim nicks in PCGS rattlers and NGC and ANACS slabs.

 

I've seen some amazingly bad "rim bites" in EVERY holder.

 

James

[jerseyboy]

I would sure grade it if I were them, just because it is so beautiful. I'd buy the coin rim nick or not (but then again, I'm a sucker for toning like this).