First Submission - Whatdya Think

[jgrinz]

Hey its my first submission to NGC and Lets see what you experts think on how many will make the grade out of

001 1878 7TF REV OF 78 S$1

002 1878 8TF S$1

003 1878 7/8TF S$1

004 1878 CC S$1

005 1897 S$1

[HaydenTubbs]

pictures! We need PICTURES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[jgrinz]

daaahhhh there out for getting incarcerated - How da heyl am I gonna do that now aye

[Merc]

I would guess none. Damage, harsh cleanings and PVC are the main reasons to bodybag a coin. As long as you submit problem free coins, there should be no bodybags.

[cpm9ball]

???????????????????

 

Chris

[HaydenTubbs]

???????????????????

 

Chris

 

 

[EZ_E]

Hey its my first submission to NGC and Lets see what you experts think on how many will make the grade out of

001 1878 7TF REV OF 78 S$1

002 1878 8TF S$1

003 1878 7/8TF S$1

004 1878 CC S$1

005 1897 S$1

 

That's like asking, "Gee, don't you think that my wife is purdy? w/o a description or a photo.

 

[jgrinz]

Basically the question is relating MORE towards the NOOB submitting coins than the actual coins itself. Speaking as a NOOB I really dont know the criteria that is acceptable OR NOT acceptable to NGC before it is body bagged aka nicks bag marks tone and genuineness of the coin even.The one really bothering me is the 1878cc which has a nick on the rim - I know they allow 'minor' issues to a certain point and where that point is I certianly dont know.All these coins were broken out of TPG slabs and I allowed them a generous 2 point drop in the grade from the break out as the TPG are less than what I woud consider elite.These graders grade insanely high and I would be happy with a two point drop in grade to procure them in a NGC holder. OF COURSE the nick was not seen until removed from the holder.

[michael]

good luck eith this and keep me informed

 

maybe one possibly two will get bagged is what i think

 

maybe none!!

[jgrinz]

The answer is IN

 

001 1878 7TF REV OF 78 - MS62

002 1878 8TF S$1 - MS63

003 1878 7/8TF S$1 - BB Improper Cleaning

004 1878 CC S$1 - MS62

005 1897 S$1 - MS61PL

 

The answer is obviously ONE. Unfortunate but true

[jom]

003 1878 7/8TF S$1 - BB Improper Cleaning

 

My question is: Would they have slabbed it if it was a "proper cleaning"?

 

 

jom

[truthteller]

003 1878 7/8TF S$1 - BB Improper Cleaning

 

My question is: Would they have slabbed it if it was a "proper cleaning"?

 

 

jom

 

 

PCGS would grade cleaned coins, NGC is much more hesitant, ANACS fallback is the net grade.

 

 

TRUTH

[jom]

PCGS would grade cleaned coins....

 

No! Who'd a thunk it?

 

jom

[jgrinz]

Are you serious that PCGS would slab this

It is a clean ms64 too with 5 tailfeathers showing one of the most

I think - Is there a designation for 6

[jom]

Are you serious that PCGS would slab this

It is a clean ms64 too with 5 tailfeathers showing one of the most

I think - Is there a designation for 6

 

No, TT was being general. I've seen many cleaned coins in PCGS holders. In NGC holders too. They must have been "properly" cleaned though.

 

jom