Looking for a thread about a 1922 Transitional Dollar from a Goldberg Sale

[CaptHenway]

About a year ago? Or two? There was quite a lively discussion about the attribution of the reverse. Was it here, or ATS?

 

THx.

 

TD

[RWB]

Both --- last April/May -- are they the ones?

[CaptHenway]

Seems to me it was at least a year ago. IIRC, the piece had been misattributed as a reverse of 1922 and you showed why it was a reverse of '21 due to the top of the second A in AMERICA and other characteristics.

[RWB]

The entire reverse is different - not just the top of the "A." But that must have been someone else -- I remember many people here and on PCGS noting the obvious...and PCGS insisting they were right....until after the auction when they quietly admitted they were wrong.

[CaptHenway]

That's the thread. I just use the top of the A as the most obvious point. The defect in the rays on the right and the rays below the tail were also brought up.

[CaptHenway]

Anybody?

[RWB]

Is this the one?

 

"No TrueView of the 1922 HR Peace $?"

 

or this: "1922 Peace PR67 Matte Finish Hi Relief" ?

[CaptHenway]

No, this was last year IIRC.

[RWB]

That's all I found....maybe someone else will have better searching luck.