1884CC Morgan

[slcoin]

Anybody want to take a shot at these photos? These are the sellers pics.

 

TIA

[Deerefan8420]

Sure, I'll take a shot. I'd give it a 62-63. From the pictures, the Obverse looks nice. There are a few hits on the cheek and a few scattered marks in the fields. The Reverse looks pretty clean from what I can see. Very nice though!

[wdrob]

 

MS63

[slcoin]

I agree with the 62-63 range. The reverse looks really clean, but may just be the image. The seller has 3 1883CC and 3 1884CC, this is the only picture I have but will see them on Thursday.

[slcoin]

Will TPGs grade these in the GSA holder?

[Deerefan8420]

I believe NGC will grade these in the GSA holders.

[wdrob]

 

Yes. Don't take them out of the GSA holders. Some only look for them in the holder.

[jpcienkus]

Will TPGs grade these in the GSA holder?

 

MS62-63 and yes, NGC will definitely grade these in the holders. They are more valuable that way.

 

ANACS will also grade these in the holder, but PCGS will not. PCGS will but GSA Hoard on their label once it's slabbed, but IMO, you'd rather keep it in the OGP. NGC will garner more return in the market than ANACS, so if you want it graded, your best choice is NGC.

[JOBESSI]

ms62...to much chatter on the obverse imo

[johnny9434]

ms 62/63, to many chatter marks.

[morganguru]

63, yes ANACS and NGC will sticker it in the GSA plastic. PCGS should do the same.

[yonico]

Anacs/NGC will grade in the holder, PCGs will remove from holder and note "GSA HOARD" on their slab.

I think being a CC GSA, it will grade 63. TPG's tend to go easy on GSA Carson city dollars for some reason. I don't know for sure why, I hear people say it's because pf how they were transported..? But they really do.

[jpcienkus]

Anacs/NGC will grade in the holder, PCGs will remove from holder and note "GSA HOARD" on their slab.

I think being a CC GSA, it will grade 63. TPG's tend to go easy on GSA Carson city dollars for some reason. I don't know for sure why, I hear people say it's because pf how they were transported..? But they really do.

 

Agree about the grading of GSA's. I've seen 65's that should be 63's and those aren't isolated incidents.