1839-C

[cameron12x]

Thoughts on a technical grade?

 

 

Eye appeal?

[$ilverHawk]

XF with a chance at AU. Cleaned.

 

Carl

[FishyOne]

AU50 and likely in a problem-free holder. I think the cleaning would be viewed as market acceptable on a Charlotte G$5 piece. It might have been netted down to 45 for it though.

[L1ncolnF4n]

AU-53 and I would expect it in problem-free.

[coinman_23885]

AU50 and likely in a problem-free holder. I think the cleaning would be viewed as market acceptable on a Charlotte G$5 piece. It might have been netted down to 45 for it though.

 

This. I don't think the coin should be in a problem free holder, but I have seen lightly cleaned southern gold coins in problem free holders in the past.

[BillJones]

It is probably in an AU-53, but I'd give it an AU-50. The piece has been lightly cleaned, but this is the Charlotte mint, and the graders cut those coins some breaks. I have a $5 Charlotte coin that has been cleaned that I probably should not have bought it, but it's mine.

 

Here it is.

 

PCGS called this on an AU-58.