My First CAC

[cameron12x]

Guess the grade (revealed later).

 

 

There are a few hits here and there, but I love the patina and toning for the grade...

 

 

[Bruceswar]

Strong XF 45... Possible as hish as AU 55... Being you mentioned CAC.. I would say AU 50

[James_OldeTowne]

My gut reaction is VF-35, but Seated dollars tend to show less proportional detail than smaller denominations, so I'll guess EF-40. The three digs above the eagle's head, and the one off the to the obverse lower left are distracting, but only minimally so.

[michael]

scarcer date seated dollar and in demand as such as a regular first year date

 

upper end xf-45+ ......................................................... yes plus

 

good eye appeal

good original surfaces at least from the photos

 

i like this coin!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[physics-fan3.14]

Fantastically original EF-45. I love it!

[nunfa0]

I agree, EF45 and a wonderful coin!!!

[cameron12x]

Thanks everyone for your grade guesses and kind comments...

 

I'll reveal the actual grade later tonight.

[BillJones]

I'd say EF-45. It looks to be a wonderful original coin.

[JOBESSI]

AU 53

[coinman_23885]

Guess the grade (revealed later).

 

 

There are a few hits here and there, but I love the patina and toning for the grade...

 

 

The obverse holds this down to XF45 for me.

[cameron12x]

Lots of very accurate assessments!

 

 

[Mark T]

Fantastic coin !! I was going to bid on that coin but the price went past

my max price. Nice circulated original Seated Dollars are not easy to come by these days .

 

 

[cameron12x]

Thanks!

 

I paid a little more than I wanted but I really liked the details and the natural crusty look of this example.

 

Although I don't like them the hits are not too bothersome and are overshadowed by the other positive attributes of the piece, IMHO.

[Mark T]

Thanks!

 

I paid a little more than I wanted but I really liked the details and the natural crusty look of this example.

 

Although I don't like them the hits are not too bothersome and are overshadowed by the other positive attributes of the piece, IMHO.

 

Most circulated Seated Dollars are banged up , those marks are not a problem for me.

[nunfa0]

Cameron, for the pleasure this coin is going to bring you it was worth every penny!!

[James_OldeTowne]

Thanks!

 

I paid a little more than I wanted but I really liked the details and the natural crusty look of this example.

 

Although I don't like them the hits are not too bothersome and are overshadowed by the other positive attributes of the piece, IMHO.

 

Most circulated Seated Dollars are banged up , those marks are not a problem for me.

They are a slight problem for me, but that's coming from the perspective of grading early copper, where such marks would knock off about 5 points. I had guessed EF-40, and would likely have gone to EF-45 without the marks. But when all's said and done, it looks like a rock-solid terrific coin, nicely graded and way nicer than all the scrubbed up examples on the market. It's a keeper!

[Walkerfan]

I agree with the majority--XF 45!

 

**Edit**-I didn't see that you posted results, so I will go ahead and say the PCGS got it RIGHT this time!!