REAL guess-the-grade: 1844 Seated Liberty dime, answer posted when I know it!

[James_OldeTowne]

This is a real "guess-the-grade", because even I don't know the correct answer yet. But I just submitted this coin today. When the grades get back in, I'll post the results. However, I will do so in a single "results" thread, since the title of this thread won't be changeable by the time grades get back. Image is accurate for color and luster. Enjoy!

 

[physics-fan3.14]

I'll grade this a choice F+. I don't really know anything about these, but I don't think its quite got what it takes for a VF.

[Schatzy]

I am not very good at these lower grades but I'll say VF-20

[fishfinder]

VF-25

[michael]

15-20

[123cents]

Very nice! VF-20.

[BillJones]

VF-20. It's decent for the grade, but it just barely makes it.

[rrantique]

VF-25

[dean1345]

VF-20

[MikeInFL]

VF-20

[Mark T]

I am also in the Vf 20 camp

[HiHoAudio]

VF-20

[James_OldeTowne]

My guess is: VF-20, and one of my favorite coins. I am the proud owner of three Little Orphan Annie dimes.

[James_OldeTowne]

Grade revealed: PCGS graded this coin F-15. I think that's a touch conservative, but the majority of guesses were spot-on. Thanks for all the guesses!