Guess the grade on a recent NGC submission

[Dwaine]

First up is a 1957 D Franklin

 

1956 P Franklin:

 

1957 P Franklin:

 

1955 P Franklin:

 

1959 D Franklin:

[Schatzy]

1957-D MS65FBL

1957-P MS65FBL

1956-P MS65

1955-P MS64

1959-D MS64

[Dwaine]

Close, one of the is right

[Schatzy]

Close, one of the is right

I only have 1 right!!

[physics-fan3.14]

Woohoo, a Franklin grading thread.

 

57D - MS65

56 - MS65 (nice toning )

57 - MS64

55 - MS64+ (borderline, btw, is that a Bugs Bunny? This one would definitely FBL at PCGS, but not at NGC))

59D - MS65FBL (can't really tell if its FBL from the pictures, but odds are strongly in your favor on this date)

 

Nice coins, but the top 3 definitely do not have FBL, at least looking at them from these pics.

 

[Schatzy]

New Guess

1957-D MS65

1957-P MS64

1956-P MS65

1955-P MS65

1959-D MS65FBL

[coinman1794]

From the pictures, I would guess:

 

MS65FBL

MS64

MS65

MS65

MS65FBL

 

NGC is inconsistent on mint set toned Franklins, though usually very conservative on them.

[Dwaine]

1957-D - MS65

1956 - MS65

1957 - MS65

1955 - MS64FBL

1959-D - MS64FBL

[Schatzy]

Dwaine I really like the 1955!!

[Dwaine]

Make me an offer and it might be yours.

[steph1942-migration]

OK,and I know this is wrong as I'm grading on brilliance:

 

MS64

MS60

MS62 cleaned

MS65

MS65

Geez, I'd like 1 right too!