Which would you prefer on your slab?

[BillJones]

I've seen more consistent high quality on Eagle Eye marked coins than I have seen on CAC marked pieces. But I’m not a fan of either.

[James_OldeTowne]

I've seen more consistent high quality on Eagle Eye marked coins than I have seen on CAC marked pieces.

This agrees with my observations.

 

It's discussions like this that lead me to be very thankful that the majority of my collection is not even in slabs, much less littered with stars and stickers. I don't ever plan to sell those coins in my core collection, so I really could not care less what a "third party" thinks of MY coins.

 

I can thumb through my albums and enjoy the COINS without being distracted by NOISE.

 

[stinkycheese1]

Eagle eye? What the heck? Is this ANOTHER "fourth party" service?

[Oldtrader3]

Kevin, Don't be alarmed. Rick Snow of Eagle Eye Coins Inc. puts an "Eagle Eye" sticker on slabs containing flying eagle and indian head cents which he sells that meet his certain, defined, quality standards.

[just-john]

Kevin think eagle eye guys are in Tucson and they only do copper cents Indians and flying eagles

[heinlein99]

Man, the whole coin-collecting world is a big mystery to me. Better stick to comics for a while.

[lehigh96]

I have seen very few original, attractive 19th century coins in NGC star holders. I have seen more with CAC stickers. I stand by decision to take the green bean over the star.

 

Found one in auction right now and I really, really want it. 1896 Barber Half Heritage

 

 

 

Post Auction Buy Price: Only $28,750.

[dean1345]

Shane,

 

Another beautifully toned Star*. Great pickup.

 

Dean (thumbs u

[Just Bob]

Post Auction Buy Price: Only $28,750.

 

I was surprised when I saw that the bid on this coin didn't meet the reserve of $25,000. I am glad that I didn't take Mark up on that bet.

[dean1345]

AMEN.

 

 

Dean