will the rim ding BB this half dime?

[rons]

Do I submit or just enjoy it raw? If you care to hazard a grade guess, please do

 

 

 

It looks like I have goofed up the image size but it conveys my concerns about the rim ding at 3o'clock. Thanks for your input

[Dwaine]

It might help if you cropped out so much of the black background and got more of the coin in the picture.

[TomB]

The ding might preclude slabbing at PCGS or NGC, but the coin appears far too light to have a natural skin and this might be due to a past cleaning or a dip. If the coin was cleaned then there would be little chance of certification at PCGS or NGC.

[James_OldeTowne]

I think it will get bagged.

[123cents]

I think it will get bagged.

 

Sorry, I think the same.

[dooly]

(thumbs u

 

this any better

 

[MikeInFL]

Enjoy it raw -- I don't believe, from the photos, that the coin will make it into a PCGS/NGC slab. I believe it would be bagged for the dipping/cleaning and/or the ding...Mike

[okbustchaser]

will the rim ding BB this half dime?

 

No, but the polishing will.

[rons]

Thanks for the input I realize I need to work on my photography skills but I am light years ahead of where I was 3 months ago thanks to the forum and suggestions from Rey and others here I know the pictures weren't great but what clues do I look for to indicate polishing or cleaned. Under magnification I don't see any lines that would be caused by polishing as they are random and scattered in all directions. What am I overlooking? Thanks again for all the assistance.

[conqueror]

Thanks for the input I realize I need to work on my photography skills but I am light years ahead of where I was 3 months ago thanks to the forum and suggestions from Rey and others here I know the pictures weren't great but what clues do I look for to indicate polishing or cleaned. Under magnification I don't see any lines that would be caused by polishing as they are random and scattered in all directions. What am I overlooking? Thanks again for all the assistance.

 

Here are my three examples:

first clean and retoned

[/img]

Next, recently cleaned and polished

[/img]

Finally, a problem free example

[/img]

I hope I got this right, for I'm still learning just like you Ron.

 

John

[Snowman24]

if you want it in a slab - send it to ANACS

 

they will grade almost anything - even if has been cleaned or has some damage on it but they will put the condition on the label- naturally

 

Snowman