PastorKen

I'm just a amateur coin collector..grade makes no difference to me like I said before I'm 46 I'm a ordained minister and been saving coins here and there most all.my life but the Morgan dollars are what really got me interested I only have several and recently got some eagles to add I like the old design better imo

I recently got a new 23 and will all the new design coins have the M mint mark I have a 21 t2 and a new 23 both with the W mint mark most older ones don't the other eagles I got are in capsules but very nice BU condition....but shortly after talking to you my coin disappeared from the registry why I called them right away and I posted what I was told

One last thing I'll say I first registered this coin back on April 7th ...so today isn't the first time I've been in the forum on this specific coin

I just wanted to say I'm not looking for this coin to be rare or valuable I'm not looking to make money off it I just wanted some advice on what I should do with it

And I agree with USA BOB ...that's why I asked questions here i though their request to send it back to be downgraded wasn't right

I read it somewhere in the ngc grading system about how they grade coins if I mistakenly read it I'm sorry but I read it as a 69 yes can have defects but they shouldn't be visible without some magnification

That's the only reason I asked questions on THIS forum because I thought I'd get the best information possible

I'm sorry it's not counterfeit it was up there since 2009 ....I'm sorry for asking questions...I guess I need to not ask people who could possibly give me advice

I contacted them and asked why it was pulled the original picture showed the coin as it is with that line through the center....when someone posted the link like I said the picture was different...I called them and asked why did you pull my coin...they said they'll check on it but it should be back up tomorrow...hopefully....they really shouldn't have pulled it ...they said it was my choice to send it in or not...

It was registered under my name with the pictures I have and when It showed up the pictures were the same it's not counterfeit...lol no but earlier when that one response showed the link to my coin the pictures changed so I retried to insert my pictures..?? So idk what happened

I absolutely agree that " bag marks" on a more recent coin honestly shouldn't happen there are examples but I apologize the marker circle actually covers another line right at the outer edge and I asked this question because so many collectors I know ... non expert but still some years of experience tell me to have it looked at by another expert because for NGC they don't want to do anything but grab a coin and check it but nothing against them it's just I thought bag marks were a thing of the past with coins now I see circulated coins in near pristine condition and these are supposed to be handled slightly better....but thanks

Thanks for the replies...I'm not trying to make a "big deal" about the coin ..but as I said they originally graded the coin 69 "nearly perfect to the eye" but the circle below the left hand is too noticeable to be a 69 and when I contacted NGC they told me they wanted it back to downgrade the coin to a 66 or 67 now I don't care if some of ya'll feel that doesn't matter that's your opinion but let me know what graded eagles you got I can buy at spot ...which is more or less what someone said ...smh I was only looking for for more options on what I should do with it tbh I could care less that's it's graded or not and yes I didn't knotice it when I bought it because it was some years ago and the marks in the center looked like it was supposed to be there ..it wasn't till about a year ago that I saw it next to a newer coin and realized that wasn't supposed to be there ...but thanks for ya'lls input I know what I'll do...

That's my problem idk who would buy it and how they would.."see" the coin (grade) and I'd just buy other coins I want..but alot of friends online who collect say keep it and definitely don't send it in ...again I'd rather sell it and NOT lose money and just buy others or straight up trade for others...and graded coins aren't so important for that reason you stated plus the premiums are just ridiculous and fakes ...very good fakes are flooding the market more and more it's disgusting

No 69 isn't perfect but by their standards it shouldn't have any visible defects...

I'm sorry yea typo...I missed it I got bad eyes ...I'm 46 been just collecting small things since I was young...got some nice coins..gold too rich for my blood but love to have it and I absolutely agree and if they make a mistake which that's no SMALL miss there should be some sort of error labeling because it shouldn't be then less valuable that's wrong when some common coin could have a stupid mint mark error ..missing ..off..ect and be worth hundreds in really crappy condition but a near perfect fully silver coin loses value.? I just don't know what to do ...because I'd have to pay to send it back..?

I've had this coin only a few years I bought it off someone who sold as a MS 69 coin but for whatever reason I just realized there's a line right across the middle of the coin that very visible and shouldn't be there contacted NGC so they're now aware..24 year later? But request I send it In to be downgraded...I feel that's not right one idk what exactly that line is ...they made the error grading it big time and to send it in have it "downgraded" without any kind of recognition of the mistake loses me money on the coin...what to do ??

Ok thank u and here's the pictures. I would think those would make it less than a 69 I have bu coins that look better

I recently registered my silver eagle it's a 2009 and it's been graded ms69 but looking closer at it there's 3 almost chip looking features below the left hand ...I haven't seen it before...is it an error and why wasn't it caught when graded ?