FloridaFacelifter

Thank you Ali! Yes my set contains 31 coins, and I went through the process of declining the transfer 31 times yesterday. It's just a pain to have to do- and if I had been on vacation and not looked at my email for a week conceivably I could come home and the set would be gone! And we're talking a #1 set with 12 "Best in Category" wins. It's dishonest, deliberate, and should warrant a ban in my humble opinion. 

On 9/21/2022 at 9:54 AM, Ali E. said:

Hello.

We currently see no pending transfer requests in your name or the other collector's name, so you must have successfully rejected them all. We have reached out to the collector. Thank you for letting us know about the situation. If it does happen again, please let my team know via email at registry@NGCcoin.com.

On 9/20/2022 at 4:57 PM, Zebo said:

Have you talked to NGC about it? Should be easy enough to stop.

I did message Ali E. directly but thought a little public shaming was in order,and who knows maybe there are other victims?

Every couple of years this piece of work tries to transfer all of my coins into his sets- what gives? Is this some type of criminal game I'm not aware of? Its a pain in the butt having to deny 35 transfers

The coins are identical- coin for coin. That's why I posted two photos showing identical proof Morgans with identical toning. It's a small community- Laura at Legend is his dealer, she is also probably the one who posted both sets and crossed the coins.

I hope so- as I mentioned previously I buy coins, not holders- so I have a mix of NGC and PCGS. Honestly I don't care what holder a coin comes in if it's the right coin for me, and I have never crossed over a coin. I was active in the NGC Registry but not the PCGS Registry because NGC accepted both PCGS and NGC coins, and when NGC dropped PCGS coins I stopped posting to the Registry. Now I'm coming back, as I suspect others are as well, and I hope they will do more to clean up the Registry.

I really think PCGS and NGC should report crossovers to each other so the old number/listing could be removed. That would help reduce so many duplicates and inaccurate pop reports

More rant? Simpson has a bunch of sets in the NGC registry (for example the #2 proof Morgan Dollar set)- he has subsequently recertified all of these coins with PCGS, put them in sets in the PCGS registry, and not deactivated his NGC sets. So the same exact coins currently occupy the #2 sets in both the PCGS and NGC registries. One set is in PCGS holders, one set is in NGC holders- but they are the exact same coins. 

More rant? Simpson has a bunch of sets in the NGC registry (for example the #2 proof Morgan Dollar set)- he has subsequently recertified all of these coins with PCGS, put them in sets in the PCGS registry, and not deactivated his NGC sets. So the same exact coins currently occupy the #2 sets in both the PCGS and NGC registries. One set is in PCGS holders, one set is in NGC holders- but they are the exact same coins. 

1802 Proof Bust Dollar- 4 known