Old soap bar slab. Will it grade higher through NGC?

[TON Collection]

[Davids5104]

I cant tell for the photo, but I would be most concerned about losing the dmpl and not a point drop

[Just Bob]

Pics are a little fuzzy, but I don't think that one would get an upgrade. 64 looks right to me. And, although the mirrors are nice,  like Davids5104 said, it might get knocked back to PL.

Good looking coin, though.

[TON Collection]

11 hours ago, Just Bob said:

Pics are a little fuzzy, but I don't think that one would get an upgrade. 64 looks right to me. And, although the mirrors are nice,  like Davids5104 said, it might get knocked back to PL.

Good looking coin, though.

Hey bob Thanks for the advice on the 84O.  If you don’t mind taking a look at this franklin and your opinion on if it is capable of 67 FBL through NGC.

[Just Bob]

The lines are not complete all the way across, so no FBL for that one. As for the grade, I honestly can't grade toned coins very well from pictures, because the toning tends to obscure minor surface marks, at least to my eyes.

[TON Collection]

10 hours ago, TON Collection said:

1893 Carson City.  EX - 45 

 

11 hours ago, Just Bob said:

The lines are not complete all the way across, so no FBL for that one. As for the grade, I honestly can't grade toned coins very well from pictures, because the toning tends to obscure minor surface marks, at least to my eyes.

Pcgs gave it a ms 66 FBL  but I understand what you’re saying about the line it’s hard to see in the picture the Tone Covered someof the area. Franklin half dollar Exactly what I was having a hard time with grading tone coins

[TON Collection]

Just now, TON Collection said:

 

Pcgs gave it a ms 66 FBL so  I understand what you’re saying about the line it’s hard to see in the picture the Tone Covered someof the area

 

[Just Bob]

7 hours ago, TON Collection said:

 

Pcgs gave it a ms 66 FBL  but I understand what you’re saying about the line it’s hard to see in the picture the Tone Covered someof the area. Franklin half dollar Exactly what I was having a hard time with grading tone coins

It is my understanding that PCGS only requires one set of lines to be complete to get the FBL designation, while NGC requires both to be complete. That is reason for my response that I don't think it would qualify for the designation at NGC.

[TON Collection]

5 hours ago, Just Bob said:

It is my understanding that PCGS only requires one set of lines to be complete to get the FBL designation, while NGC requires both to be complete. That is reason for my response that I don't think it would qualify for the designation at NGC.

I did not no that. Well damn 

 

5 hours ago, Just Bob said:

It is my understanding that PCGS only requires one set of lines to be complete to get the FBL designation, while NGC requires both to be complete. That is reason for my response that I don't think it would qualify for the designation at NGC.