SO MUCH FOR MY GUESSES. posted by Eagles-R-it

[CSJournals-migration]

5 COINS ON WAY HOME

 

Well my coins are graded and on the way here. My Reverse Gold Buffalo wasn't a 70 and both Reverse proof Eagles were 70, the SP, a 69 by the way, I returned a SP70 to a dealer I bought it from because of a gouge in it, so how is mine a 69? The 2012 Proof eagle from the San Fran set is also a 69.

I felt they would all be 70s except for the 2012 S reverse proof, because it had like bag marks on the obverse and reverse. And here it comes in at a 70, go figure, I took good photos of them before I shipped them so we will see if they may have been miss placed. I also have a 5 star generals with a 70 grade and there are three marks across Ikes head, looks like they are from a reeded edge, very pronounced.

Well my friends my first try at sending in coins was less than hoped, that's why they are judging them and not me I guess.

Take care everyone and will have some pics up later in the week.

 

See more journals by Eagles-R-it

[Jack Robinson]

Sounds to me based on your comments that the graders did not have or, had too much, coffee before grading your coins.

 

I see your point about a SP70 gouge compared to a SP69 nongouged coin.

 

I wonder if there is a good day and a bad day to get coins graded. Maybe which shift or, who is on duty or, regular or, decaf drinkers.

 

Semper Fi !

 

Best wishes

 

Jack

[mvcoins-migration]

You can always crack-out your NGC coins and resubmit them for grading. Don't resubmit them in the current NGC holders. Why not crack-out all the 69 coins and resubmit them. Then let us know how it went. I have had some good luck with the crack-out game and no luck at all resubmitting coins in existing NGC holders. You don't have to take these graders' opinion as the final verdict.