Opinions

[jburdt-migration]

Would you do this trade? Would you give up 8 1oz silver rounds for 1 2001 proof P-Buffalo ungraded?

[L1ncolnF4n]

I, personally, would not. Your silver rounds are worth about $20 a pop, given current spot, and from what I can see the Buffalo is between $100-$200. If it was a PF-70 that's a different story, but if silver goes up to $30/oz. then you're in a better situation as the Buffalo is based on numismatic value rather than bullion.

[jburdt-migration]

thanks for the input

[braddick]

I'd trade.

[Bruceswar]

I'd trade.

 

Me too... Silver is high right now and will come down at some point. The buff is not coming down. Silver rounds are the answer if you ask me.

[123cents]

Whether you trade is your business but I certainly believe it is a fair trade.

[bartlesvilleok]

depends on the condition of the buffalo but seems like a fair trade

[SD4000-migration]

Go for the 70!!!! Take a chance

[James_OldeTowne]

Would you do this trade? Would you give up 8 1oz silver rounds for 1 2001 proof P-Buffalo ungraded?

For business purposes, I would not. I'd sell the silver immediately, buy the buffalo, and still have a few bucks left over. But as a collector, I'd rather own the buffalo any day over the silver rounds.