Guess the Grade & Overton# 1818 CBH

[saen78]

[physics-fan3.14]

Come on, next time give me a challenge That is an O-112a, no doubt about it. A very nice R5, congrats!

 

Grade, I'd call it VF-35. I think it has just a smidgen too much wear for a 40.

[okbustchaser]

While I agree with Jason that it is a VF O-112a I suspect that it is in an XF holder.

[123cents]

I would think it would grade about XF-45.

[L1ncolnF4n]

I dunno about the Overton# but EF-40

[saen78]

Yep, this is a O-112a .. PCGS graded this one VF-30.

 

 

 

 

[MBA101]

Are there any nicks and scratches to bring it down to 30? I have seen/have PCGS 1818's like this in 40 or 45 holders. Grading is so all over the map I don't even know who to believe anymore...

 

Looks pretty darn nice especially if you paid 1818 VF 30 money for it.

[coinman1794]

Definitely an XF coin, unless here is unseen damage.

[saen78]

Are there any nicks and scratches to bring it down to 30?

 

No nicks or scratches...

[physics-fan3.14]

30 seems a little harsh, but maybe PCGS is tightening up too?

[RI AL]

VF 30?

 

No way. I'd go xf 40 at the minimum. Of course I looked in my "grading books" for some guidance. Possibly a soft strike beause the clasp just isn't there.

 

RI AL