Abdulah

To Henri

Can't answer?
but as if you are a real numismatic expert! Turns out you can only be good at mocking, wow that means I'm the wrong person !!

To LOCK34

You are off track from the main point of the post,
This is about identifying differences in coins, not treating human nervous and mental damage, try taking medicine 1 once a day 3 times, hopefully it will heal

To The Krurt B
Dear sir 

The rubbish on the dollar on the right is caused by this dollar having never been cleaned at all, and the surface of the front and back of the letter bird's face and hair is smoother than the dollar on the left and the dollar on the right appears clearer. Thanks lots sir 

It turns out that many people are crazy about seeking wealth through coins, and it also turns out that there are many who claim to be currency experts but cannot explain the condition of the coins, only thinking in their brains about money and wealth, not carrying out natural investigations according to the guidelines in the Red Book and history books. Even though I only mentioned or named the coin that I have, this is the SACAGAWEA VIP FIRTS STRIKE coin, but that doesn't confirm or state absolutely that this coin is truly a SACAGAWEA VIP FIRTS STRIKE coin! Do you understand, why does it catch fire???
and in essence from this second dollar post I just want to discuss the argument about this coin that the left side is rough and the right side is smooth and clear, that's all and not wealth, so work if you want to be rich! remember NUMISMATICS IS AN ART!

On 1/14/2024 at 7:15 AM, Abdulah said:

 

To lock 34 

Seriously, what this means is that you are the richest person in the hospital??? 

TO Henri 

Hello Henri, in the world of numismatics it can be seen that your language in coin identification is very reasonable and expert and  professional with your language style and sharp sarcasm towards people, so that's why I want to ask you,
1 . Since you have been involved in the world of numismatics, has your money ever been sold at auction for a fairly decent price?
2. Do you currently have coins that have been certified by PCGS, NGC, ANAC, ICG, etc. at MS grade?
3. What achievements can you obtain while you are involved in the world of Numismatics?
4. Are you someone who works in the company PCGS, NGC, ANAC, ICG, etc. in the special grading of coin valuation?

Please answer????

TO Henri 

Can you show me Henri my sentence says what i mean is OLDHOOP? 

To KurtB
Dear Sir
I don't fantasize about this coin, and also don't fantasize about getting a lot of money from it, and I also agree and am normal in arguing that if you call it normal money and millions are circulating, however, there must also be proof from you that the dollars are exactly the same as those I have that with the dollars you have, also with the dollars in circulation in general, let's try to show it is the same or not?
Don't you see there is a striking difference between what I call the VIP first strike dollar and the regular strike dollar? This is the difference that should be discussed, not this imaginary problem that is being discussed. The main point of this argument is why the dollar that I call the VIP first strike is so Very good and smooth, the appearance of the front and back faces is also flat, the rim is different from regular strike dollars in general, here I give an example, there are Indonesian palm oil coins Rp. 1000 rupiah, both 1996, try to see the difference even though the coins were issued in the same year , please answer, thank you sir

@TheNeophyte

The question is, when do I buy my snack and will I get the money back...????? 
The Dollar 2000 P Sacagawea coin was not change! but a gift from a friend who was old or old, he was a rare coin dealer in Jakarta, he gave the coin to me when I was bidding on a certified Canadian Mepel silver coin and had a protective box, he gave me the Sacagawea Coin naked he gave coins for free ..
Sorry, you need to know that I always update reading the coin catalog at PCGS COIN FACT and I understand all US coins, sorry, actually I'm pretending to be stupid here

On 1/12/2024 at 8:30 PM, J P M said:

doing

All the coins that I post here are from my own collection which I have kept for a long time because I have a hobby of nusmismatic art, most of the American and Indonesian coins as well as Dutch colonial Indies coins, and Indonesian banknotes, ringgit and cents, are still in very good condition.
I don't know the origin of all the coins and banknotes, whether they were inherited from grandfather, etc. or when my grandmother was not born, they were already in an old cupboard, said my late mother.
Back in the 80s, paper money and cents were shared among all my relatives, but unfortunately the money was made into toys.
 
In particular, Sacagawea was a gift given to a friend, a rare coin dealer in Jakarta who was quite old, he gave the coin naked, I thought it was an ordinary coin, I have kept the coin for a long time, maybe there is still a certificate and a protective box for the dollar in it. there, because a few days ago I saw the Canadian silver coin that I was hunting for along with the certificate and protective box which were still well stored, it is possible that the certificate document and protective box of the Sacagawea Dollar are still there or stored there. I will look for that document.

On 1/12/2024 at 3:10 PM, Henri Charriere said:

An MS-68 is an extraordinarily high grade for a coin. And yet you present it raw with no documentation to support your claim. Have you any special documentation or packaging to support your claim?  With those in hand, you would not need to resort to explanation of any kind.  And with certification the coin you claim is special could speak for itself. Frankly, you come across unsure and somewhat defensive. If the narrative does not fit, I would not 

Yes, I really agree with you Carriere , that's the weakness of this dollar, it doesn't have a special box and a certificate of origin This dollar was first received by a special guest, This dollar traveled to Indonesia naked 9 years ago, in condition like the photo, and not yet cleaning it completely, I finally kept it in a special plastic coin container until now. I hope too
maybe you have the best advice for me about this coin. thanks Henri carriere

On 1/12/2024 at 8:25 AM, Henri Charriere said:

absolutely

Yes, I really agree with you Henri, that's the weakness of this dollar, it doesn't have a special box and a certificate of origin This dollar was first received by a special guest, This dollar traveled to Indonesia naked 9 years ago, in condition like the photo, and not After cleaning it completely, I finally kept it in a special plastic coin container until now. I hope too
maybe you have the best advice for me about this coin. thanks Henri

Dear sir how about this 1909 VDB my Colection RD or BN ? 

1. Vip firts strike
2. 

Vip First Strike  REGULAR STRIKE REGULAR STRIKE 

Minting machines for medals and tokens have better results
and medal and token minting machines can only mint less than hundreds of millions of metal pieces
Medal or token.

This is different from coin minting machines in general, where the minting  results are not as good as minting machines specifically for medals and tokens

So it is clear that these genuine VIP dollars are made using a medal and token minting machine because the appearance is very smooth and very clear and not rough and the edges or rims are flat

On 1/12/2024 at 10:56 AM, The Neophyte Numismatist said:

Guess you are right.  Submit it.

Edit note: My analysis.  I went to your profile and read all your posts.  Every coin you post is about an error that isn't.  You are batting 1000.

On 1/12/2024 at 10:56 AM, The Neophyte Numismatist said:

Guess you are right.  Submit it.

Edit note: My analysis.  I went to your profile and read all your posts.  Every coin you post is about an error that isn't.  You are batting 1000.

On 1/12/2024 at 10:56 AM, The Neophyte Numismatist said:

Guess you are right.  Submit it.

Edit note: My analysis.  I went to your profile and read all your posts.  Every coin you post is about an error that isn't.  You are batting 1000.

On 1/12/2024 at 10:56 AM, The Neophyte Numismatist said:

Guess you are right.  Submit it.

Edit note: My analysis.  I went to your profile and read all your posts.  Every coin you post is about an error that isn't.  You are batting 1000.

On 1/12/2024 at 9:07 AM, The Neophyte Numismatist said:

No. You do not have a special coin.  Your coin was not stuck by a medal press by mint staff. It's just an ordinary SAC dollar.

How do you know,

Do you immediately think that this is just an ordinary dollar without a clear thesis? Even though in the history of cemony it has been explained that the condition of VIP dollars is that the OBVERSE and REVERSE surfaces are very smooth and the writing is very good, neat, there are also differences in the RIM , different from ordinary dollars, because what could happen like this? because these dollars are made with medal molds, try to pay attention to the very big difference between the two. dollar.

On 1/12/2024 at 6:41 AM, The Neophyte Numismatist said:

I see nothing special about your coins.  There is no VIP issue.  There are valuable varieties, but these are not those.  You have $2 in value. 

Please explain the results of your analysis in detail and be sure that if the dollar is an ordinary coin, where did you learn about specifically AMERICAN coins?

Sacagawea on the right is Dollar VIP Firsts Strike and on the left is Dollar Regular Strike, this is my assessment

  Rare VIP Sacagawea 2000-P First Strike Coin. On November 18, 1999, the United States Mint in Philadelphia held a special ceremony marking the inception of the Sacagawea “gold coin.” An invitation-only event of just under 600, each guest was given the opportunity to manually mint one of the first coins. After doing so, Mint staff recorded their contact information and each was sent their own coin the following year. This is one of those coins. The available pieces have much higher relief and finer detail than the typical 2000-P Sacagawea coin, as each VIP coin is struck using a medal press. Recognized by SEGS and ANACS as a unique coin in the Sacagawea series, SEGS has awarded this coin a “First Strike/VIP, MS-68” certification rating. Included in the lot is a Sacagawea VIP First Strike 2000-P coin, its original box, and a certificate of authenticity.

In fact, it's actually red RD, not brown BN, but because of the lack of lighting and the effect of reflections around it, it looks like it's dark, it looks like BN

It's a shame that the LINCOLN CENT 1909 RD VDB obverse has scratches, what do the numismatic experts think on this forum?
Is the scratch really from an initial strike error?